Debate Club

Ryan Plan Would Crush Seniors Beneath Mounting Medical Costs

By SHARE

Republican Mitt Romney's desperate attempt to revive his presidential campaign by picking House Budget Chairman Paul Ryan as his running mate has not made Ryan's Medicare plan a better idea. It's still a lousy scheme that would be disastrous for the middle class because it would replace healthcare security for seniors with crushing medical expenses.

The Ryan privatization plan does nothing to strengthen Medicare or control rising healthcare costs. Instead it would make seniors pay more than $6,400 for their healthcare in order to give tax breaks to the wealthiest Americans and corporate special interests like Big Oil.

The Ryan plan trades seniors' guaranteed healthcare benefits for vouchers to buy private health insurance. The value of the vouchers would grow at a slower rate than the private insurance premiums. When premiums, co-payments, and deductibles are raised, seniors would be on their own.

[See a collection of political cartoons on healthcare.]

The Ryan-Romney plan is designed to end Medicare as we know it. The plan would herd new enrollees into a privatized Medicare program while current Medicare enrollees become older and sicker. That would increase costs in the Medicare program, which has always been far more efficient and cost-effective than private insurance.

The Ryan-Romney plan would repeal the Affordable Care Act, or ACA, and cut preventive benefits and drug discounts for seniors now and in the future, while shortening the life of the Medicare trust fund by seven years.

Meanwhile, Romney and Ryan would raise the Medicare eligibility age from 65 to 67, making it even harder for people to retire, let alone retire with any security.

[See a collection of political cartoons on Mitt Romney.]

The ACA is already closing the Medicare prescription drug donut hole and preserving the program for future generations. The law eliminates waste, fraud and abuse, including overcharges by private insurers, so that young people will have access to the same quality Medicare system seniors enjoy today.

The Ryan-Romney plan would leave many seniors without nursing home coverage by making deep cuts to Medicaid that would bankrupt millions of middle-class families struggling to shoulder the costs of long-term care. Nursing home care in the U.S. costs $74,800 a year on average, but the median household income is only $52,000. No working family can manage these expenses.

The Ryan-Romney Medicare plan is not a legitimate healthcare proposal—it's just another GOP attack on our country's shrinking middle class and the promise of the American Dream.

Ethan Rome

About Ethan Rome Executive Director of Health Care for America Now

Tags
Ryan, Paul
Medicare
health care
Romney, Mitt
2012 presidential election

Other Arguments

#2
4 Pts
Paul Ryan's Medicare Plan Harnesses Consumer Power in Healthcare

Yes – Paul Ryan's Medicare Plan Harnesses Consumer Power in Healthcare

James Capretta Fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center

#3
4 Pts
Ryan Plan Turns Medicare's Promises Into Real Dollars, Not IOUs

Yes – Ryan Plan Turns Medicare's Promises Into Real Dollars, Not IOUs

Nina Owcharenko Director of the Heritage Foundation's Center for Health Policy Studies

#4
-20 Pts
Medicare Needs the Ryan Plan's Cost Controls

Yes – Medicare Needs the Ryan Plan's Cost Controls

Michael D. Tanner Senior Fellow at the Cato Institute

#5
-20 Pts
Ryan's Plan Is Our Best Hope for Increasing Medicare Efficiency

Yes – Ryan's Plan Is Our Best Hope for Increasing Medicare Efficiency

Joseph Antos Wilson H. Taylor Scholar at the American Enterprise Institute

#6
-21 Pts
Paul Ryan's Plan Is Dead on Arrival

No – Paul Ryan's Plan Is Dead on Arrival

Jamie Chandler Political Scientist at Hunter College

You Might Also Like


See More