Voter ID Laws Keep Our Elections Secure


The Justice Department has no basis for suing Texas under Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act (VRA) over its voter ID law. And it presents no evidence to support its claim under Section 3 that Texas should be placed under federal supervision for any additional changes in its voting laws for the foreseeable future.

Requiring voters to prove that they are who they say they are when they show up to vote is overwhelmingly supported by the American people no matter what their racial, ethnic or political background. Moreover, it has been upheld as constitutional by the U.S. Supreme Court, in an opinion written by former Justice John Paul Stevens, a liberal stalwart.

States such as Georgia and Indiana have had voter ID laws similar to the Texas law in place for years. The turnout of black and Hispanic voters in their local, state and federal elections was not affected by the ID requirement, disproving the claims of critics that ID requirements suppress anyone's vote.

[See a collection of political cartoons.]

That's not surprising. The vast majority of Americans have photo ID. Only a small percentage of registered Texans don't already have a state-issued driver's license or state ID. And the Texas law stipulates that — as is the case in every other state with a voter ID requirement — the state will provide a free photo ID to anyone who doesn't already have on.

People in this country need a photo ID for everyday activities — from filling a prescription to cashing checks. You need to present ID to buy a beer or cigarettes; check into a hospital or hotel; apply for public assistance; get a marriage license; buy a gun; hop an airplane … even just to enter the building that houses the U.S. Department of Justice.

Is it really too much to ask for ID when it comes to exercising something as important as the right to vote? Don't we deserve to have fair and secure elections that are not stolen by fraudulent votes? Voter ID is not the only step needed to improve the integrity of our election process, but it is a basic step that is neither discriminatory nor unconstitutional. It is just common sense.

Hans A. Von Spakovsky

About Hans A. Von Spakovsky Senior Legal Fellow at the Heritage Foundation

Department of Justice

Other Arguments

16 Pts
Texas' Voter ID Laws Are Plain and Simple Discrimination

Yes – Texas' Voter ID Laws Are Plain and Simple Discrimination

Natasha M. Korgaonkar Assistant Counsel of the Political Participation Group at the NAACP's Legal Defense Fund

3 Pts
The Justice Department Is Defending American Democracy

Yes – The Justice Department Is Defending American Democracy

Marc Veasey Democratic Representative from Texas

0 Pts
The Justice Department Is Doing its Part to Protect Texas Voters

Yes – The Justice Department Is Doing its Part to Protect Texas Voters

Trey Martinez Fischer Democratic Representative in the Texas State House

You Might Also Like

See More