Home > Debate Club > Is the Cordray Appointment Constitutional? > The President Abused His Power

The President Abused His Power

Obama's purported recess appointments are unconstitutional and unprecedented

Reader Comments
Back to argument

The article does not address this part of the Article II clause:

" but the Congress may by law^^ vest the appointment of such inferior officers, as they think proper". What does that mean in this context? Is that specifically in this bill, established in statute generally somewhere for all instances, or made ironclad by SCOTUS or unchallenged lower court findings? Is precedent of action or custom enough to legalize the appointment, as has been argued elsewhere? Reportedly, Republicans ended the sought consent through filibuster...does that make a difference in the legality of a recess appointment. ( I think you did address that, are there contrary arguments? I wonder..Is the fiat appointment arguably a cause for a vote for impeachment, whether that would be confirmed or not? Is the status or acceptance of recess appointments arguably as risky for the Minority as for the Majority

JOYCE CLEMONS of OH 6:24PM April 14, 2012

There are many unusual circumstances that contribute to Obama's decision to make an appointment during a recess. Obama has made a case for his reasons, and whether in ends up in court or not, the House had not agreed to this recess, which may very well alter a court's decision about the legality of Obama's appointment.

ann keenan of MI 2:01AM January 09, 2012

The Senate is not in town-as a factual mattter they are in recess. The Senate (and House) are violating the Constitution by taking a recess of longer than 3 days without the consent of the other. US Marshals shoud go round them up and bring them back to the capital and lock them in until they consent to a recess. The Senate cannot block Obama from recess appoints by violating the Constitution.

Additionally, the Constitution does not prohit recess appointments in recesses shorter than 3 days.

Jim of IL 9:06PM January 07, 2012

Obama lifting the restrictions on the sale of equipment and military equipment to South Sudan

so ur president want to blow up the world like gorge.w.b

ahmed 4:33PM January 07, 2012

Congress is _only_ in session when they have a quorum. They are not in session just because they have three people click a gavel in a large empty room. Congress is the one using illegal tactics to disrupt constitutional powers granted to the president.

Jimmy The Geek of OH 6:22PM January 06, 2012