Is Rick Santorum More Electable than Mitt Romney? >
Only Santorum Addresses Values Issues that Concern Voters
Rick Santorum connects on social issues in a way Mitt Romney has not
February 22, 2012
About Gary Bauer:
Gary Bauer is the president of American Values, chairman of the Campaign for Working Families, and a former presidential candidate.
Electability is notoriously difficult to measure. Democrats cheered when Ronald Reagan was nominated in 1980, because they thought he was the least electable Republican. And many wise Republicans were sure Vietnam War hero John McCain would be much more electable than the relatively unknown Barack Hussein Obama.
Despite its limits, the electability standard is worth considering. I'm surprised that Gov. Mitt Romney is regarded by some as the most electable Republican candidate. Romney has lost more elections than he's won, and this year he has run decidedly worse in virtually every state compared to his vote total in 2008.
[See a collection of political cartoons on Mitt Romney.]
Romney is more moderate than former Sen. Rick Santorum, and that's supposed to be a plus for him. Some commentators believe that only a moderate Republican can win a majority of voters. But apparently moderates disagree with that analysis. Recent polling shows Romney's standing among moderates has plummeted.
People often conflate independents and moderates. But a significant share of independents are disgruntled conservatives who will vote Republican only if the party nominates a conservative candidate like Santorum.
We are not living in an ordinary time in America. The conventional wisdom tells us that this election will be determined by economic issues. But polls show that many Americans sense that the country is on the wrong path not just economically but also on matters of the heart. To millions of Americans, our widening virtue deficit is just as worrisome as the fiscal deficit.
And better than any of the other candidates, Santorum has been able to speak to Americans' concern that for our nation to regain its strength, we must address fundamental cultural issues such as out-of-wedlock birth and absentee fathers. He is the only candidate who's been willing to tell the American people what the Founders believed—that only a virtuous people can remain free.
[See pictures of Rick Santorum.]
Finally, Santorum's popularity stems in part from the sense that many voters have that he understands them and their concerns—that he is a regular guy who can empathize with the challenges they face. This is a real asset in an election year in which Barack Obama seems willing to run a divisive, class warfare-based campaign.
Republican economic policies will help the working class of America. But it will take a candidate with working-class roots to effectively make the case on Election Day.
- See pictures of Mitt Romney.
- Join the debate on Facebook.
- Follow U.S. News Debate Club on Twitter.
- Other Arguments
-
#111747
No — Rick Santorum's ideology is far too right and his campaign organization far too weak to win the presidency
JAMIE CHANDLER, Professor at Hunter College
-
#28827
No — Support of evangelists will not make up for independents, moderates, and women Santorum turns away
LARA BROWN, Professor at Villanova
-
#310346
No — Romney would fare slightly better than Santorum vs. Obama, but both primary campaigns need work
FORD O'CONNELL, Republican Strategist, Conservative Activist, and Political Analyst
-
#46541
Yes — Mitt Romney's record is weighing him down
TONY PERKINS, President of the Washington, D.C.-based Family Research Council Action
-
#55938
Yes — Voters can trust Rick Santorum; they can't trust Mitt Romney
BOB VANDER PLAATS, President and CEO of The Family Leader
-
#73138
No — Santorum makes for easy fodder for Obama, but neither addresses concerns of fiscal conservatives
JUDSON PHILLIPS, Founder of Tea Party Nation
Reader Comments Read all comments (3)
Stacy H of FL 4:50AM March 07, 2012
brenda ward of IN 2:43PM February 22, 2012
Heather W. of CA 1:31PM February 22, 2012