Debate Club

It's Not the Economy, Stupid--It's Entitlement Spending

By + More

No president—President Obama included—is captain of the USS Economy. Presidential actions rarely have dramatic effects on the macro-economy in the short run (and almost never in a positive direction). But voters tend to believe otherwise, in part due to the promises of candidates and the media's portrayal of presidential power. As a result, a president's electoral fortunes are closely linked to the state of the economy come election time.

[See pictures of Obama's re-election campaign.]

Instead of judging the president on the short-run performance of the economy, Americans would receive a far greater benefit from judging the president's performance in an area over which he and Congress have direct control: entitlement spending. The reform of programs like Medicare would have significant long-run economic benefits by reducing the risk of a future debt crisis and alleviating fears that government spending will increasingly crowd out private sector activity. When creditors lose faith in a country's ability to pay its debts, the consequences are immediate and severe—just ask Greece and other euro zone members. And even if default is not imminent, the steady increase in entitlement spending diverts money to the government from the private sector, which constrains consumers and investors today through higher taxes or tomorrow through debt repayment.

[Romney, Gingrich and Santorum Battle in South.]

For politicians, these risks pale in comparison to the significant electoral risks associated with entitlement reform. And President Obama, like most politicians, values re-election above all else. Until voters begin punishing incumbents who refuse to make difficult choices—instead of rewarding those who avoid hard choices—entitlement reform will not be a priority. Presidents will continue to take credit and receive blame for an economy over which they have little control, and the country's fiscal picture will continue to worsen.

President Obama has offered no meaningful proposals to restructure Medicare and other entitlement programs, the biggest threats to our fiscal future. Judged on these terms, President Obama receives a failing grade.

David Primo

About David Primo Author of 'Rules and Restraint: Government Spending the Design of Institutions'

Tags
Obama administration
economy
Obama, Barack

Other Arguments

#1
281 Pts
Obama Has Tried All the Wrong Policies

No – Obama Has Tried All the Wrong Policies

Daniel Mitchell Senior Fellow at the Cato Institute

#3
63 Pts
Obama's Policies Have Not Turned the Economy Around

No – Obama's Policies Have Not Turned the Economy Around

William W. Beach Director of the Center for Data Analysis at The Heritage Foundation

#4
-143 Pts
President Obama's Policies Revived the Economy

Yes – President Obama's Policies Revived the Economy

Andrew Fieldhouse Federal Budget Policy Analyst at the Economic Policy Institute

#5
-153 Pts
Obama's American Recovery and Reinvestment Act Has Been a Success

Yes – Obama's American Recovery and Reinvestment Act Has Been a Success

Heather Boushey Senior Economist at the Center for American Progress

#6
-210 Pts
Obama Deserves Credit for the Recovery

Yes – Obama Deserves Credit for the Recovery

Dean Baker Author of 'The End of Loser Liberalism: Making Markets Progressive'

You Might Also Like


See More