Debate Club

The U.S. Can't Control the World Oil Market


Oil prices drive gasoline prices and current oil prices are high. But $125 per barrel oil today is no more the fault of President Obama than $147 oil was President Bush's fault in June 2008. There is very little the U.S. president can do to change oil prices over months or a few years. U.S. oil production was up 13 percent in 2011 over 2008, but still remains less than one-tenth of the world oil market.

[What Obama and Ben Bernanke Should Do About Gas Prices.]

Producing more oil domestically will enrich the U.S. economy, particularly U.S. oil companies and their workers. With oil so valuable, it may be a good idea, though the value must be weighed against environmental consequences. But it will have no discernible impact on gas prices, because it will change the world's supply/demand balance for oil by less than 2 or 3 percent over a decade or more.

In fact, the impact on gas prices would probably be about the same as the recent increase in U.S. fuel economy standards will have over the next 20 years: somewhere between very little and none. The advantage of doubling fuel economy is that it will halve the cost of driving even if it has no impact on gas prices.

[Republicans Aggressively Gouging Obama Over Gas Prices.]

Many on the left, and a few on the right, argue that misguided or nefarious speculation in oil futures markets has driven oil prices well above their true competitive level. The claim, however, is rejected by nearly all economists across a broad range of political perspectives, from Paul Krugman to the Heritage Foundation. Speculation can cause short-run increases in oil price—on the order of days or weeks—but eventually if the price doesn't equate real physical demand with real physical supply, a massive buildup of inventories puts downward pressure on prices.

So what does drive the price of oil and therefore gasoline? The real physical suppliers do, especially Saudi Arabia. The Saudis hold more spare capacity today than the U.S. could bring online in the next decade even if all federal lands were opened to drilling. Likewise, the factors that drive the physical demand for oil, particularly the growing demand from China, India, and other developing countries, push up U.S. gas prices.

[How High Gas Prices Could Help Obama.]

Those factors aren't going to change anytime soon. Even with the new drilling technologies, most oil production and the vast majority of reserves will remain in the Middle East and Africa. And the growth of oil demand from the developing world is much more likely to accelerate than abate. We need to adapt to this changing world, hoping that new supplies keep prices under control, but preparing for a world with permanently higher gasoline prices. Nothing the politicians are going to say or do will change those hard realities.

Severin Borenstein

About Severin Borenstein E.T. Grether Professor of Business Economics and Public Policy at U.C. Berkeley's Haas School of Business

Obama administration
Obama, Barack

Other Arguments

153 Pts
Obama Doesn't Have an Answer for Rising Gas Prices

Yes – Obama Doesn't Have an Answer for Rising Gas Prices

Daniel Simmons Director of State Affairs at the Institute for Energy Research

57 Pts
Obama Can Do Something About the Struggle at the Pump

Yes – Obama Can Do Something About the Struggle at the Pump

Douglas Holtz-Eakin President of the American Action Forum

35 Pts
Obama Can Control Some Factors That Affect Oil Prices

Yes – Obama Can Control Some Factors That Affect Oil Prices

Christopher Prandoni Federal Affairs Manager of Americans for Tax Reform

-8 Pts
Gas Prices Shouldn't Be a Political Football

No – Gas Prices Shouldn't Be a Political Football

David Friedman Senior Engineer and Deputy Director of the Union of Concerned Scientists' Clean Vehicles Program

-46 Pts
Obama Is Not the Only One to Blame for High Gas Prices

No – Obama Is Not the Only One to Blame for High Gas Prices

Nicolas Loris Policy Analyst in the Roe Institute for Economic Policy Studies at the Heritage Foundation

You Might Also Like

See More