Debate Club

Going Over the Fiscal Cliff Is Bad Policy—and Bad Politics Too

By + More

Even though the so-called "fiscal cliff" is really a fiscal slope, going over it could still produce significant harm to an already weak economy, and should be avoided.

Many Democrats think they can win the political game, by letting the Bush tax cuts expire this year, and then pressuring the Republicans to join them in voting early next year for the reinstatement of the Bush tax rates except for those brackets above $200,000 ($250,000 for joint filers).

But this may be bad politics, overestimating the willingness of the embittered and radicalized Republican right to compromise in order to avoid holding middle class tax cuts hostage to low tax rates on the rich.

[See a collection of political cartoons on the fiscal cliff.]

And even if it is good politics, it is bad policy. While going off the cliff would not lead to immediate disaster, it would produce plenty of harmful effects—the abrupt end of the payroll tax cut for American wage earners, cuts in unemployment benefits, and budget uncertainty for private businesses and public agencies alike.

A "grand bargain" that attempts to combine major long-term tax reform with long-term entitlement reform is not necessary. What is needed instead is a "mini-deal" that defuses various ticking time bombs for the next few months. Only when job creation and growth are stronger should we take up major fiscal reforms. In this situation, kicking the can further down the road is the most responsible option.

Michael Lind

About Michael Lind Cofounder of the New America Foundation

Tags
economy
deficit and national debt
fiscal cliff
Democratic Party

Other Arguments

#1
421 Pts
House GOP Should Make a Debt Ceiling Deal on Fiscal Cliff

No – House GOP Should Make a Debt Ceiling Deal on Fiscal Cliff

Ford O'Connell Republican Strategist, Conservative Activist, and Political Analyst

#3
55 Pts
Expiring Tax Relief Would Hammer Middle Class

Yes – Expiring Tax Relief Would Hammer Middle Class

Pete Sepp Executive Vice President of the National Taxpayers Union

#4
-40 Pts
Going Off the Fiscal Cliff Is Good Policy­—If You Like Unemployment

Yes – Going Off the Fiscal Cliff Is Good Policy­—If You Like Unemployment

Bill Frenzel Guest Scholar in Economic Studies at the Brookings Institution

#5
-43 Pts
The Fiscal Cliff Is an Exaggerated Crisis

No – The Fiscal Cliff Is an Exaggerated Crisis

Alan Barber Domestic Communications Director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research

#6
-46 Pts
The Risks of the Fiscal Cliff Are Uncertain But Real

Yes – The Risks of the Fiscal Cliff Are Uncertain But Real

James Capretta Fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center

#7
-60 Pts
Better Billionaires Go Over the Fiscal Cliff Than Senior Citizens

No – Better Billionaires Go Over the Fiscal Cliff Than Senior Citizens

Brad Bannon President of Bannon Communications Research

#8
-94 Pts
There Are Worse Things Than Going Over the Fiscal Cliff

No – There Are Worse Things Than Going Over the Fiscal Cliff

Patrick Sharma Explainer-in-Chief at Newsbound.com

You Might Also Like


See More