No Evidence of Groundwater Contamination From Fracking

The economic benefits of the shale gas boom outweigh unproven risks

Reader Comments

Back to argument

Even a cursory Google search shows multiple cases of fracking groundwater contamination-and they are under-reported because in many states Frackers are allowed to regulate & report themselves without oversight. Since he begins with a bold-faced & easily refutable lie, I would guess the "institute" he works for is funded by the fracking industry.

Latveria of NY 10:58AM November 30, 2011

Our planet's climate may already be melting down due to our nation's overconsumption of fossil fuels. Keeping the gas pipelines full should not be our primary concern right now. We should be pouring our capacity for innovation into the development of non-polluting energy sources, not into extracting more of a limited resource that's destroying our planet's life systems. In the long run, all we really accomplish by improving our natural gas extraction technology is to increase the severity of future energy shortages and climate impacts.

Marty Hiller of NY 10:48AM November 30, 2011

If the chemicals they use are so safe, why do gas drillers need exemptions from the Clean Water Act, Clean Air Act, and the Safe Drinking Water Act? Liz, KeepTapWateeSafe.org

Liz Rosenbaum of PA 9:44AM November 30, 2011

In Eastern Pa. the Delaware River Basin provides water for much of NY, Phil., etc. The soil is not conducive to fracking. In Western Pa we already have mined for coal, leaving the populations perched on old mine shafts and mines filled with poisonous water. Fracking is being considered a possible reason for the recent earthquakes in Oaklahoma. The frack ponds are a danger to wildlife and the evaporation increases toxic air pollution. Since there is no oversite, the drillers just dump frack water in ponds and creeks, illegal dumping is rampant. The 'shills' for the industry are lying. Go see a well for yourself....they destroy community and environment.

Lisa VALANTI of PA 10:00PM November 29, 2011

In Eastern Pa. the Delaware River Basin provides water for much of NY, Phil., etc. The soil is not conducive to fracking. In Western Pa we already have mined for coal, leaving the populations perched on old mine shafts and mines filled with poisonous water. Fracking is being considered a possible reason for the recent earthquakes in Oaklahoma. The frack ponds are a danger to wildlife and the evaporation increases toxic air pollution. Since there is no oversite, the drillers just dump frack water in ponds and creeks, illegal dumping is rampant. The 'shills' for the industry are lying. Go see a well for yourself....they destroy community and environment.

Lisa VALANTI of PA 9:59PM November 29, 2011

Any who have read Dr. Devra Davis' book "The Secret History of the War on Cancer" understand that American history is replete with examples of industries that sicken their workers and the public at large, but because they generate jobs and are generally run by powerful people who buy government influence, these industries (mostly oil and gas, petrochemicals and of course tobacco) get away with poisoning people and the environment time and time again. They generate a "science of doubt" to hide the truth.

The gas industry is not doing anything new to sell itself. It is using tried and proven methods of bamboozling the public, and causing untold suffering such as the cancer my late wife just endured, in order to enrich a few. I would not want to be living in the skin of those who would willingly and knowingly sicken others for private gain. Six months ago my wife was the picture of health, running our farm dairy business. Now she's dead. The gas industry is surely going to condemn many more people to such an awful end to their life as she had to suffer.

The term “responsible oil and natural gas exploration” should be understood as a chimera (a foolish fantasy) when it is used in the context of endorsing the extreme form of fossil fuel extraction known as high volume slickwater fracturing of long laterals into tight shale deposits. In light of ample and mounting evidence that unconventional drilling is fraught with environmental and public health perils, the notion that there can be any kind of “responsible drilling” of this kind is a chimera. It enables an industry to operate that should be halted until we have conducted a comprehensive, long-term study of the environmental and public health risks. There is not any such long-term study. Nor is there any scientific consensus that this type of gas extraction cannot cause irreparable environmental harm - from above or from below. We allow this drilling in direct contradiction to the Precautionary Principle.

Stephen Cleghorn of PA 5:33PM November 29, 2011

Industry whore

Rodger Hamer of NY 1:48PM November 29, 2011

Institute for Energy Research -- Koch funded

ALEC -- Koch funded

Well gee, I just can't figure where this author gets his marching orders!

jimspice of WI 1:29PM November 29, 2011

Dan,

There is currently widespread contamination across America's gaslands, even though Science hasn't caught up with the problem - yet.

The fact that communities fracked 10-20-30+ years back have never been re-visited to investigate if the toxic waste pumped into the ground has migrated up to the water table over time doesn't give a clean bill of health to the gas industry.

In fact, in the "gaslands" of Pavillion, WY, there is scientific proof that fracking has already contaminated ground water and this is just the beginning of the EPA's investigation, so your overly optimistic pronouncement is premature, to say the least (not to mention based on nothing more than industry assurances, making your position an example of the "faith based" approach to gas drilling).

Richard of NY 1:15PM November 29, 2011

Like I would trust Daniel Simmons on this matter. I'm no idiot and I see the energy companies (yes I know I use energy) extracting profits any way they can at the expense of people and their livelihoods. I take that personally. Your lies and twisted facts don't wash anymore. We are awake and we are the 99%!

People Over Profits! of FL 12:53PM November 29, 2011

<1 2 3>

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.
About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.

Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.

You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
Republicans Can't Forget the Economy During Obama Scandals

Scandals provide good fodder for the GOP, but it can't forget about fixing unemployment.

Amidst Obama Scandals, Republicans Prepare a New Debt Ceiling Hostage

Republicans are preparing to take the debt ceiling hostage…again.

Benghazi, IRS and AP Scandals Reveal a Clueless President

The recent slew of scandals reveals an administration either incompetent or malicious.

The IRS Scandal Is About Budget Cuts, Not the Tea Party

Cutting the tax collection budget hurts everyone in the long-run.

Obama 'Going Bulworth' Wouldn't Give Him Power Over Republicans

Both Congress and presidents overestimate the power of the Oval Office.

Bureaucracy Keeps Adopted Children Stuck in International Limbo

The U.S. needs to do more to ease the international adoption process.

The Real Scandal Behind the Benghazi Emails and Attacks

The GOP focuses on talking points while ignoring dangerous security budget cuts.

House Republicans Waste Time With Obamacare Repeal Vote

Why is the House bothering to repeal Obamacare yet again?

Advertisement