Debate Club

Fracking Is Not a Solution

By SHARE

Too many of America's government officials, nonprofit organizations, and private citizens are caught up in a futile effort to "manage" fracking, when we need to ban the practice altogether (as is already happening in parts of our nation and around the world).

"Fracking," and the entire process of shale gas extraction, is not the solution to our energy challenges, as the oil and gas industry portrays it to us; instead, it is scraping the bottom of the geological barrel, bringing unacceptable health, climate, and environmental consequences while delaying and distracting us from developing energy policies to ensure our children's future.

[See a slide show of 10 reasons Americans aren't talking about climate change.]

Marcellus Shale Protest advocates a total ban on shale gas extraction, instead of "regulation", because:

  1. Our scientific understanding is inadequate for responsible risk management. The environmental and health consequences of shale gas drilling are hard to measure, but pervasive and potentially irreversible. Proposed regulations address only those substances for which we already have criteria. The chemical mixture in "fracking fluid" is only one of many sources of environmental contamination; abandoned capped wells, after economic production ends, will be hazards for millennia to come--far longer than all human experience with concrete and steel.
  2. The industry's campaign of disinformation has hijacked public dialog. Citizens can't realistically appraise "risk-benefit" decisions when they are shouted-down by phony claims of imagined economic security and "energy independence," and while their actual experience (deteriorating health, destruction of property values, diversion of water and crop-land) is mocked and trivialized, and court cases remain sealed.
  3. Democratic institutions are being corrupted by industry money and power. Elected officials, university researchers and educators, consultants, and media outlets can't be relied upon to advocate for the public interest when they depend upon donations and revenues from industry.
  4. A false sense of urgency has been created. There is no near-term domestic demand for shale gas (which, ultimately, will be exported for higher margins to Asia). In truth, energy companies desperately need to prop up their accounting house-of-cards, of which "proven reserves" and "acreage held-by-production" are the foundation.

The gas industry promises to "do it right," when there is no such thing; and, in our current political climate, there is no chance of holding this industry accountable. Marcellus Shale Protest views the media fixation upon regulations and taxation as missing the point, and we continue to insist on a total ban as the only responsible public policy.

John Detwiler

About John Detwiler Private Citizen with Marcellus Shale Protest

Tags
energy policy and climate change
natural gas
gas prices

Other Arguments

#3
121 Pts
Fracking Is Destroying Our Groundwater

No – Fracking Is Destroying Our Groundwater

Tracy Carluccio Deputy Director of the Delaware Riverkeeper Network

#4
108 Pts
Natural Gas Is an Energy Solution That Works Today

Yes – Natural Gas Is an Energy Solution That Works Today

Jon Olson Associate Professor in the Petroleum and Geosystems Engineering Department at the University of Texas at Austin

#5
105 Pts
Fracking Threatens Public Safety and Health
#6
37 Pts
No Evidence of Groundwater Contamination From Fracking

Yes – No Evidence of Groundwater Contamination From Fracking

Daniel Simmons Director of State Affairs at the Institute for Energy Research

#7
16 Pts
Learn the Hard Lessons of Coal Pollution

No – Learn the Hard Lessons of Coal Pollution

Trent Dougherty Director of Legal Affairs for the Ohio Environmental Council

#8
6 Pts
Shale Reserves Mean Security for U.S. and Its Oil and Gas Industry

Yes – Shale Reserves Mean Security for U.S. and Its Oil and Gas Industry

Chris Faulkner Founder, President, and CEO of Breitling Oil and Gas

#9
-22 Pts
Fracking Technology Has Been Used Safely for Years

Yes – Fracking Technology Has Been Used Safely for Years

Lee Fuller Vice President of Government Relations for the Independent Petroleum Association of America

#10
-48 Pts
Mining of Shale Gas Makes Sense

Yes – Mining of Shale Gas Makes Sense

Gregg Laskoski Senior Petroleum Analyst for GasBuddy.com

You Might Also Like


See More