Debate Club

Obama's Proposed Defense Budget Cuts Leave Us Vulnerable

By SHARE

This question reminds me somewhat of the little kid in the back of the car asking, "Are we there yet?" Seeking a safer America is a trip that never ends. Security is not a goal to be achieved but a condition to be maintained.

[Check out our editorial cartoons on President Obama.]

So the real question is: Will President Obama's policies keep us safe in the future? Here there is real cause for concern. Planned cuts to defense and intelligence will take us back to the forces we fielded in the 1990s—forces that struggled to meet minor contingencies such as Bosnia and Kosovo. This left us unprepared for the world we faced after 9/11.

It's difficult to envision a force at this level being able to deal adequately with the security challenges we may face in the future. Other instruments of power are not a ready substitute for preparedness—for the capacity to address today's concerns and deter tomorrow's threats.

In fact, the opposite is true. Our diplomacy is most effective, our economy flourishes the most, and our liberties are best secured when we demonstrate the ability to protect ourselves and our interests.

[Read What Barack Obama's 'Forward' Slogan Really Means.]

President Obama's promise of a "peace dividend" is illusory. Under the cuts he has proposed, we will not be strong enough to protect ourselves or to promote peace.

James Jay Carafano

About James Jay Carafano Director of the Heritage Foundation's Douglas and Sarah Allison Center for Foreign Policy Studies

Tags
Obama administration
Obama, Barack
foreign policy
federal budget

Other Arguments

#1
163 Pts
Obama Got Bin Laden, but Other Threats Have Grown

No – Obama Got Bin Laden, but Other Threats Have Grown

Edward A. Turzanski National Security Analyst at La Salle University

#3
128 Pts
Obama Keeps al Qaeda at Bay, but Handcuffs the CIA as Well

No – Obama Keeps al Qaeda at Bay, but Handcuffs the CIA as Well

Nathan Sales Law Professor at George Mason University School of Law

#4
-17 Pts
Obama Has Made America Safer, but He Could Use Help

Yes – Obama Has Made America Safer, but He Could Use Help

Lawrence Husick Co-chairman of the Foreign Policy Research Institute's Center for the Study of Terrorism

#5
-34 Pts
Obama Learned From Bush's Mistakes and Successes

Yes – Obama Learned From Bush's Mistakes and Successes

James Dobbins Director of the International Security and Defense Policy Center at the RAND Corporation

#6
-41 Pts
President Obama Deserves Credit for Keeping Us Safe

Yes – President Obama Deserves Credit for Keeping Us Safe

William F. Daddio Adjunct Professor at Georgetown University

#7
-108 Pts
6 Reasons America Is Safer Under Obama

Yes – 6 Reasons America Is Safer Under Obama

Lawrence J. Korb Senior Fellow at the Center for American Progress

You Might Also Like


See More