Debate Club

More Smoke and Mirrors From Obama's Latest Budget

By + More

Well, the president's budget is here and it is as underwhelming as usual. That is not the official line, of course. The message the president wants you to believe is that his budget is an act of political courage that takes on entitlement reform, finishes the difficult job of debt reaction, and does both in a balanced manner.

The centerpiece of this claim is the proposal to slow Social Security spending (the so-called chained CPI proposal) and that's not nothing – the left is already up in arms over it. The only problem is that by itselfit amounts to peanuts – $250 billion compared to CBO's estimate of $7 trillion in new deficits over the next ten years – and it does not really address the fundamental solvency problems of the system itself.

[See a collection of political cartoons on the budget and deficit.]

As for the remainder, there are the usual rosy economic assumptions, budget gimmicks (I simply defy anyone to decipher so-called Table S-2, which is supposed to explain how the budget reduces the deficit), and tax-heavy proposals.

After all the smoke fades and the mirrors crack, what is left? An apples to apples to apples comparison shows that the House budget reduces deficits by $4.6 trillion over ten years, the Senate's by $600 billion, and the president's by $580 billion.

So the president spent his extra time finding a way to spend the $700 billion in new taxes and put off the job of repairing the nation's finances. What he didn't spend his time doing is reducing the debt.

It's hard to call that courageous.

Douglas Holtz-Eakin

About Douglas Holtz-Eakin President of the American Action Forum

Tags
deficit and national debt
federal budget
Obama, Barack
politics

Other Arguments

#1
22 Pts
Obama Accepts the Agenda of Misguided Washington Elites

Yes – Obama Accepts the Agenda of Misguided Washington Elites

Dean Baker Codirector of the Center for Economic and Policy Research

#2
6 Pts
Obama's Budget is Bad Policy and Bad Politics

Yes – Obama's Budget is Bad Policy and Bad Politics

Andrew Fieldhouse Federal Budget Policy Analyst at the Economic Policy Institute

#3
4 Pts
Obama Gives the GOP What It Hasn't Asked For

Yes – Obama Gives the GOP What It Hasn't Asked For

Robert Reich Professor of Public Policy at the University of California-Berkeley

#5
0 Pts
The President's Budget Is No Move Toward the Center

No – The President's Budget Is No Move Toward the Center

James Capretta Fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center

You Might Also Like


See More