Debate Club

Has Christmas Become Too Secular? >

Christmas Can't Become Too Secular

We have taken the opportunity to come together and positively celebrate our diversity

December 22, 2011

About Roy Speckhardt:

Roy Speckhardt has been the executive director of the American Humanist Association since 2005. He also serves as a board member of the Humanist Institute, the Secular Coalition for America, Institute for Humanist Studies, the United Coalition of Reason, and as an advisory board member of the Secular Student Alliance.

No, Christmas has not become too secular, because it can't be too secular. December in America today is a time to spread a message of good cheer by reuniting with family and friends, and it need not have anything to do with the sacred. To many atheist and agnostic humanists, this time of year transcends religion and deities, which is why it is enjoyed not just by the most faithful but by all who appreciate goodwill and community. Anyone can celebrate and participate in the traditions of the season, including giving gifts, hosting parties, and spending time with family and friends. In fact, many humanists take this opportunity to recognize America's diversity by celebrating not just Christmas, but Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, and Winter Solstice celebrations, among others. We like winter holidays so much we humanists even invented a new one, HumanLight! In a move that is very American at its core, we have taken the opportunity to come together and positively celebrate our diversity.

[Lowe's Intolerant for Pulling Ads From "All-American Muslim".]

Those on the Religious Right claim there's a "war on Christmas" and insist that only Christmas be celebrated publicly and only in their distinctly sectarian way. That only fuels further intolerance of Americans of minority faiths and philosophies who enjoy this time of year and recognize Christmas and other December holidays for what they truly are--a time for peace and giving, getting together with family and friends, and celebrating humanity. This is not to say that Christians can't enjoy a sectarian Christmas of their own, though it's worth pointing out that many Christmas rituals and practices we observe today have ancient pagan roots and a long history of accepting adaptations from various cultures. But there's no doubt Christmas today has become a civic holiday that can be celebrated by all--and that's a good thing.

 

 

Tags:
holidays,
religion,
Christianity
Other Arguments
#1
#2

No — The Winter Solstice is the reason for the season

ANNIE LAURIE GAYLOR, Co-president of the Freedom From Religion Foundation

#4

No — Christmas in America has always been a secular holiday

HERB SILVERMAN, Founder and President of the Secular Coalition for America

#5

Yes — Go ahead and doubt, or just join in while we believers enjoy the season

JANICE SHAW CROUSE, Senior Fellow of Concerned Women for America's Beverly LaHaye Institute

#6

Yes — Christmas is a celebration of Jesus's birth

ANDREA S. LAFFERTY, President of Traditional Values Coalition

#7

Yes — Crackdown on religious free speech can't be ignored

J.P. DUFFY, Vice President for Communications at Family Research Council

#8

Yes — Because of Jesus, we live in the best country in the world

TIM WILDMON, President of American Family Association

#9

Yes — Who are the anti-Christmas police protecting when they seek to smash Christmas?

BILL DONOHUE, President and CEO of the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights

Reader Comments Read all comments (7)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

I suppose it is quite humanistic to enjoy sharing in any part of life, including diversities of opinion. Nonetheless, to suggest "Christmas" as devoid of religion significance is a stretch, and the typical American has no concept of a "solstice." As for "religion," whatever it is in life for which a person really lives is his or her real religion, and all that he or she does in regard to that for which he or she really lives is worship. America's real religion is "democracy," the social and political expression of the principle which acknowledges mankind as a family, a family nation in which citizens of all religions and of none are welcome to share in all of its social and political functions. However, "strongly guarded as is the separation between Religion and Government in the Constitution of the United States, the danger of encroachment by Ecclesiastical Bodies may be illustrated by precedents already furnished in its short history," James Madison. If there is one principle upon which our nation is founded, it is that "religion" shall not be established by law or government at any level. Law is the essence of coercion. In the USA, "religion" is to be freely exercised, that is, voluntarily. You can read more in my Amazon.com book--The Religion Commandments in the Constitution: A Primer.

Gene Garman of KS 10:54PM December 25, 2011

The risk taken when promoting a predominantly secular holiday season is the close alliance of secularism with the capitalist promotion of guilt for not giving enough gifts or buying expensive gifts. Lexus would suggest that giving a new car is normal and a standard of giving that one should strive for.

So the notion of good will and generousity and sharing with friends and family needs to be parsed from guilt over the quantity or size or expense of gifts.

And since the original notion of Christmas was tied to the birth of Christ, it helps to explain that a secular Christmas is taking the spirit of joy and community associated with Christ's birth and saying that joy and community can be directed to friends and family at these shortest darkest days of the year without the baggage of Christianity.

David of OR 3:15PM December 23, 2011

I like Christmas Trees. And jolly fat elfs. I like jingle bells, egg nog, holly, wreaths, candy cane shaped sugar cookies. I like giving and receiving presents. I especially like the moment of suspense during the unwrapping of gifts.

Once in my life, I leaned towards believing in the bearded, thorn crowned man in the bible. At that time I thought those who didn't should leave his holiday alone, to give thoseof true faith the room to express their profound religious belief.

Now, I agree with the author of this piece. Secular Christmas may be an oxymoron, like jumbo shrimp. Yet I know from experience that both exist. And just like the guy who invented the b flat trumpet probably didn't intend to produce an instrument that would play jazz, well, now we have jazz. To me secular christmas is like a cultural jazz. You take what you want, you express yourself and your values, and hopefully spread some joy to those around you.

Semantically speaking, christ is not a name. It comes from a word that means "the anointed". So we need not get so uptight about the "Mass of the Christ" terminology inherent in the word christmas. Take it as a time to anoint those near to you and far, with the blessings of your love.

Secular Christmas. Cause it feels good.

Just some guy of CA 12:23PM December 23, 2011

About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.


Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.


You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
Donald Trump Makes Kim Kardashian Look Good

At least Kim Kardashian doesn't take herself seriously.

The Vietnam War Still Haunts Us

History rhymes once again, thanks so much.

'Transcripters' Make Birthers Look Smart

Now the fringe right wants the president's university grades to prove he wasn't a good student.

Obama Must Do More to Protect the Intellectual Property Industry

The Obama administration needs to protect the industry's creativity and innovation.

Is Congress Getting Dumber?

That Congress is speaking at a lower grade level than it was seven years ago may be due to the unfortunate tendency to equate education with elitism.

Obama's Remarkable Silence on Latin American Press Abuses

President Obama's silence on press freedom in Latin America is troubling.

Why the Media Is Giving Romney a Pass on Trump's Birtherism

Why the media hasn't pressed Mitt Romney about Donald Trump's birther fantasies.

Romney's Bain Experience Wasn't Real American Capitalism

The fact that Bain Capital served to make money for investors, not to create jobs, could endanger Romney.

Advertisement