Debate Club

Has Christmas Become Too Secular? >

Be Good, Accept Diversity, and Strive for Peace

Christmas in America has always been a secular holiday

December 22, 2011

About Herb Silverman:

Herb Silverman is founder and president of the Secular Coalition for America and distinguished professor emeritus of mathematics at the College of Charleston. After an eight-year battle, Silverman won a unanimous decision in the South Carolina Supreme Court that struck down a provision barring atheists from holding public office. Silverman is an "On Faith" panelist for the Washington Post online.

No. Christmas officially became a secular holiday on June 28, 1870. That's when President Ulysses S. Grant declared December 25 a legal holiday, along with January 1, July 4, and a day to be determined for Thanksgiving. We were founded as a secular country under a godless Constitution (no mention of God or Jesus), where freedom of conscience is guaranteed for all people. Just so there is no doubt about President Grant's intent, in his seventh-annual message to Congress on Dec. 7, 1875, he said: "Declare church and state forever separate and distinct; but each free within their proper spheres."

[Lowe's Intolerant for Pulling Ads From "All-American Muslim".]

Christians may certainly celebrate Christmas religiously. Early Christians made up a story about a savior born on December 25, a myth that originated in the winter solstice festivals of ancient civilizations. Mithras, a Persian savior-god, had a sizable following in the Roman world and his birth was celebrated on that day. By appropriating the day for the alleged birth of Jesus, Christians could more easily convert pagans.

Individuals are free to focus on whomever they view as the reason for the season: Jesus, Rudolph, or Santa. My personal preference is a Santa who wants us to be good for goodness's sake, without fear of eternal punishment for not believing in him. From Rudolph we learn that it's OK to be different, and to stand proud even if others laugh at you. And though Jesus primarily wants us to give glory to God, I like it that he also asks for "Peace on Earth and goodwill toward men."

What a wonderful world we would have in any season if we followed these three lessons: be good, accept diversity, and strive for peace. I wish this holiday season would bring us closer to such important secular principles. Unfortunately, the Christmas season has become increasingly divisive.

[Remembering Christopher Hitchens.]

A manufactured "War on Christmas" by some Christians now forces people to choose between wishing a "Merry Christmas" or "Happy Holidays." It's ironic that stores are boycotted when the emphasis is on the Happy Holidays phrase, implying that the true meaning of Christmas for religious people must be "shopping." In fact, because of the pagan origin of Christmas, some early American colonies prohibited the celebration of Christmas. That might have been the original war on Christmas.

Whether we celebrate Christmas, Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, Winter Solstice, HumanLight, or any other holiday, my wish for this and all seasons is that we strive for peace on Earth and goodwill toward all humans.

Tags:
religion,
Christianity,
holidays
Other Arguments
#1
#2

No — The Winter Solstice is the reason for the season

ANNIE LAURIE GAYLOR, Co-president of the Freedom From Religion Foundation

#3

No — We have taken the opportunity to come together and positively celebrate our diversity

ROY SPECKHARDT, Executive Director of the American Humanist Association

#5

Yes — Go ahead and doubt, or just join in while we believers enjoy the season

JANICE SHAW CROUSE, Senior Fellow of Concerned Women for America's Beverly LaHaye Institute

#6

Yes — Christmas is a celebration of Jesus's birth

ANDREA S. LAFFERTY, President of Traditional Values Coalition

#7

Yes — Crackdown on religious free speech can't be ignored

J.P. DUFFY, Vice President for Communications at Family Research Council

#8

Yes — Because of Jesus, we live in the best country in the world

TIM WILDMON, President of American Family Association

#9

Yes — Who are the anti-Christmas police protecting when they seek to smash Christmas?

BILL DONOHUE, President and CEO of the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights

Reader Comments Read all comments (6)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Actually, no Christmas has not always been a secular holiday in America. Christmas has been a holy day (from which the word holiday stems) among Catholics since at least the 4th century. Ethnics Catholics (Italians, Germans, Poles, and Irish) had a long history of celebrating Christmas prior to arriving on American shores in the 1850's, and they brought their traditions with them.

It is true that some of the Protestants who arrived early avoided Christmas. Those of a puritanical strain called the celebrations, "a vestige of popery.” It was not just because Puritans were not known from their love of celebration, but more importantly because the actual date of Christmas has no biblical basis; it was imposed by the Church to correspond with winter solstice (an important symbol since antiquity, a annual reminder that God appears when all is dark in the world). This un-biblical imposition was a remained to the Puritans that Church with a capital C was the driver of they da. Nevertheless, not all Protestants followed the Puritan lead. In fact, in the American colonies, Christmas was widely celebrated among the non-puritans. Moreover, it was only after the American Revolution, when the puritan-stock got their way. Christmas became identified with English traditions...and Americans were to be different from England. Since Protestants did not have the conception of holy days like catholics did, they could identify Christmas with national rather than a universal tradition. As a result, the Protestants in the U.S. gradually stopped celebrating under Puritan influence. But not for long.

The Catholics started immigrating in the mid-19th century. Much like Halloween, Christmas caught on until even Jews were celebrating it. By 1904, we find the New York Tribune mentioning how Santa blanketed the Jewish Lower East Side. Did retailers help bring Christmas back when a Catholic market demanded it? Sure they helped. But they did not start it, nor give the day meaning.

Despite the hope of some to make Christmas a secular day for all, they should not re-write history in trying to do so. Christmas has been an event celebrated by community and church for nearly 2,000 years. If you enjoy celebrating Christmas in America this year, no matter your creed, thank a German catholic for reminding your ancestors of a day that it has held an important place in western history for far longer than America has existed.

Merry Christmas.

John of IL 10:43PM December 22, 2011

We don't have to get superstitious and supernatural to want Peace on Earth, fellowship and hot mulled cider this time of year.

Will of SC 8:25PM December 22, 2011

So well put- be good, accept diversity, and strive for peace. I enjoy this time of year because people seem to become better people- more giving and kind and gentle- the way you would hope for them to be all year round.

Heather of PA 12:56PM December 22, 2011

About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.


Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.


You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
Donald Trump Makes Kim Kardashian Look Good

At least Kim Kardashian doesn't take herself seriously.

The Vietnam War Still Haunts Us

History rhymes once again, thanks so much.

'Transcripters' Make Birthers Look Smart

Now the fringe right wants the president's university grades to prove he wasn't a good student.

Obama Must Do More to Protect the Intellectual Property Industry

The Obama administration needs to protect the industry's creativity and innovation.

Is Congress Getting Dumber?

That Congress is speaking at a lower grade level than it was seven years ago may be due to the unfortunate tendency to equate education with elitism.

Obama's Remarkable Silence on Latin American Press Abuses

President Obama's silence on press freedom in Latin America is troubling.

Why the Media Is Giving Romney a Pass on Trump's Birtherism

Why the media hasn't pressed Mitt Romney about Donald Trump's birther fantasies.

Romney's Bain Experience Wasn't Real American Capitalism

The fact that Bain Capital served to make money for investors, not to create jobs, could endanger Romney.

Advertisement