Debate Club

Only Time Will Tell What Scott Walker's Victory Means for Barack Obama

By + More

The only intelligent answer to this question is "it all depends." For Mitt Romney to carry Wisconsin and other critical Midwestern states such as Iowa and Ohio in November, Republicans will have to repeat the enthusiasm and huge fundraising advantage that lifted Scott Walker to victory on Tuesday. But that depends on the answers to three critical questions: What will be the public's view of the economy in that region (as well as the nation at large)? Will Romney be able to excite his base and woo independents who voted for President Obama in 2008? Will the president manage to convince skeptical voters as well as his liberal base that he is willing to fight for the programs and ideas he believes in? We do not and cannot know the answers five months from election day.

[See a collection of political cartoons on the 2012 campaign.]

What Scott Walker's win does confirm, however, is the continuing power of the conservative movement. It has managed to galvanize those Americans who are hostile to unions, progressive governance, and secular elites and gain lavish funding from major corporations and individual billionaires. And, in all but name, it controls the Republican Party. Neither liberal activists nor the Democratic Party can match either its passions or its resources. The problem is that conservatives have no viable solutions to any of the major problems which plague our nation and the world—from the economic crisis to entitlement reform to global warming to promoting democracy in the Arab world. So any opportunity to make progress on these vital issues depends on re-electing Barack Obama this fall.

Michael Kazin

About Michael Kazin Author of 'American Dreamers: How the Left Changed a Nation'

Tags
Walker, Scott
Obama, Barack
Wisconsin
Romney, Mitt
2012 presidential election

Other Arguments

#1
46 Pts
Scott Walker's Win Strengthens Mitt Romney's Candidacy

Yes – Scott Walker's Win Strengthens Mitt Romney's Candidacy

John M. O'Hara Author of 'A New American Tea Party'

#2
30 Pts
Scott Walker's Victory Shows Voters Want a Smaller Government

Yes – Scott Walker's Victory Shows Voters Want a Smaller Government

James Sherk Senior Policy Analyst at the Heritage Foundation

#3
18 Pts
Republicans and Mitt Romney Will Feed Off Scott Walker Win

Yes – Republicans and Mitt Romney Will Feed Off Scott Walker Win

Ron Bonjean Former Chief of Staff for the Senate Republican Conference

#5
-10 Pts
Mitt Romney Needs to Campaign, Connect to Ensure His Victory
#6
-31 Pts
Too Soon to Tell Whether Scott Walker Paves the Way for Mitt Romney

No – Too Soon to Tell Whether Scott Walker Paves the Way for Mitt Romney

Karlyn Bowman Senior Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute

#7
-40 Pts
Walker's Win Shows Big Money Can Trump Grassroots Fervor

No – Walker's Win Shows Big Money Can Trump Grassroots Fervor

Krystal Ball MSNBC Contributor and Former Democratic Nominee for Congress

You Might Also Like


See More