Winning Words, But Not a Winner

By + More

President Barack Obama's State of the Union Address was sprinkled with fortifying words for Democrats ("Teachers matter"), needling barbs for Republicans ("No drama"), and post-partisan promises for independents ("consensus around common sense ideas"). But the speech failed to deliver a clear message or set a discernible agenda because of its noticeable contradictions.

[Pictures: Obama Delivers His Third State of the Union Address.]

More tempered than his speech last month in Osawatomie, Kan., the president continued to press on the theme of "fairness," harkening back to both President Harry Truman's "Fair Deal" and President Teddy Roosevelt's "Square Deal." Obama encouragingly proclaimed that under his watch, we would "return to the American values of fair play and shared responsibility" and "apply the same rules from top to bottom: no bailouts, no handouts, and no cop-outs."

Yet he touted the success of the federal government's "bailout" of General Motors; proposed a new mortgage refinance plan to "bailout" underwater homeowners; and urged Congress to "bailout" students facing interest rate increases on their education loans next summer.

Obama also called for "doubling the number of work study jobs," extending "the tuition tax credit," and spurring "energy innovation" by giving "businesses incentives to upgrade their buildings." He further advocated not only a "tax cut" for "American manufacturer[s]," including a doubling of the break for "high-tech manufacturer[s]" who make their "products here," but also a program to help these businesses with "financing a new plant, equipment, or training for new workers." As genuinely worthwhile as many of these proposals may be, it is tough not to characterize them as "handouts."

[With Fairness, Obama Finds a Winning State of the Union Theme.]

Beyond this, the president took no responsibility for the heated "temperature in this town," or the "inefficient, outdated, and remote" character of the executive branch. Operating in campaign mode, using somewhat veiled language, Obama laid blame on the past administration and the Wall Street banks for the weak economy, and congressional procedure, corrupt practices, and partisan gamesmanship for "what's broken" in Washington. Isn't this a "cop-out?"

Despite what may be described as Obama's honest intentions to ensure that "everyone gets a fair shot, everyone does their fair share, and everyone plays by the same rules," his speech offered up several partisan proposals that can easily be decried by Republicans as evidence of his "crony capitalist" or, worse, "socialist" inclinations toward governing. The president's State of the Union address weakened, rather than bolstered, his campaign's platform built on "fairness."

Lara Brown

About Lara Brown Professor at Villanova University

Obama administration
Obama, Barack
State of the Union

Other Arguments

41 Pts
Obama's Speech Will Be Forgotten

No – Obama's Speech Will Be Forgotten

David Crockett Author of 'Running Against the Grain: How Opposition Candidates Win Presidential Elections'

23 Pts
Obama's State of the Union Failed

No – Obama's State of the Union Failed

Ford O'Connell Republican Strategist, Conservative Activist, and Political Analyst

21 Pts
Obama's Side of the Nation's Story

No – Obama's Side of the Nation's Story

Stephanie Slade Project Director at The Winston Group

15 Pts
Obama Played It Safe

No – Obama Played It Safe

Ron Bonjean Former Chief of Staff for the Senate Republican Conference

12 Pts
State of the Union Was Typical for Election Year

Yes – State of the Union Was Typical for Election Year

Donna R. Hoffman Co-Author of 'Addressing the State of the Union: The Evolution and Impact of the President's Big Speech'

-1 Pts
Incumbents Have History on Their Side

Yes – Incumbents Have History on Their Side

Matt Schlapp Founder of Cove Strategies

-6 Pts
Obama Crafted a Winning Message

Yes – Obama Crafted a Winning Message

Krystal Ball MSNBC Contributor and Former Democratic Nominee for Congress in the First District of Virginia

You Might Also Like

See More