Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Opinion

Robert Schlesinger

Texas Secession? Perry, One Third of Texans Are Wrong: Texas Can't Secede

April 17, 2009 01:15 PM ET | Robert Schlesinger | Permanent Link | Print

By Robert Schlesinger, Thomas Jefferson Street blog

As if their current governor and his predecessor have not done enough damage to Texans' reputation for Constitutional acuity, nearly 1 in 3 Texas voters think that their state has the legal right to secede from the Union, according to a new Rasmussen Poll.

Umm, no.

On the bright side (such as it is), only 1 in 5 Texas voters would actually like to break off from the Union. Fully three quarters of Texas voters are content to remain part of these United States. Gee, thanks.

This discussion was sparked by Texas Gov. Rick Perry's assertion that Texas has the unique right to secede from the U.S. of A. (Side question: Why the quiescence of the hyper-patriotic right? Why are they not demanding that Perry love this country or leave it—and reminding him he can't take his state with him?)

It is of course an old urban legend that since Texas entered the Union as a sovereign Republic, it has reserved the right to reclaim its old status. Horse-hockey.

Two points to consider. First, there's this brief history of the Lone Star State's 1845 entry into the Union, emphasis added:

When all attempts to arrive at a formal annexation treaty failed, the United States Congress passed—after much debate and only a simple majority—a Joint Resolution for Annexing Texas to the United States. Under these terms, Texas would keep both its public lands and its public debt, it would have the power to divide into four additional states "of convenient size" in the future if it so desired, and it would deliver all military, postal, and customs facilities and authority to the United States government. (Neither this joint resolution or the ordinance passed by the Republic of Texas ' Annexation Convention gave Texas the right to secede.)

That paragraph comes from what I can only assume to be an authoritative source on the matter: the Texas State Library and Archives Commission. (Tip of my cowboy hat to an old college pal—from Texas—who posted the link on Facebook.)

Second point: We fought a war over this. Lots of Americans died. The secessionists lost—including the ones in Texas. Secession is no more legal now than it was then.

And while talking about secession undoubtedly plays well among the 3 in 10 Texas voters ill-informed enough to think it's a serious political statement, it also makes the rest of the country (and likely the rest of the state) roll our eyes in bewilderment at the Lone Star Clown.

On Facebook? You can keep up with Thomas Jefferson Street blog postings through Facebook's Networked Blogs.

Tags: Texas

Tools: Share | | Comments (496) | Print

Reader Comments

Legality

Nowhere is the right for Texas to secede specifically banned or upheld. The Texas constitution even states that it is bound by the Constitution of the United States ONLY (not the president, or other state powers).

Not saying it would be smart to secede, but don't mislead people. There is no legislation or other legal document disallowing the secession of Texas.

Please Secede. Oh please, oh please, oh please.

I have no problem with it, in fact, please secede. Oh please, please, please secede.

Texas has been a gross embarrassment for this country for far too long.

Texas secede

I know a lot of unhappy Texans ready to fight to secede from the Union. The secession movement is very much alive and growing. A recent poll advertised on KSAT12 10 pm news 02/05/2010 stated that 52% of Texans support secession. Therefore, despite the arguments against the legality of secession, I would say that poll indicates something significant is occurring here in Texas. I support secession.

Add your thoughts

Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

advertisement

U.S. News Weekly

Free Trial!

Get the new U.S. News Weekly digital magazine free for four weeks!

Robert Schlesinger is a deputy editor at U.S. News and World Report and oversees all opinion editorial content. He is the author of White House Ghosts: Presidents and Their Speechwriters.

advertisement

NEWSLETTER

Sign up today for the latest headlines from U.S. News & World Report delivered to you free.

RSS FEEDS

Personalize your U.S. News with our feeds of blogs and breaking news headlines.

U.S. NEWS MOBILE

U.S. News daily briefings are also available on your mobile device.

Thomas Jefferson St.

GOP Sets Terms for Healthcare Summit

Boehner and Cantor are forcing the president to treat the Republicans as equal partners.

Palin’s Fundraising Letter Has Bad Grammar

With all the money she spent, you’d think she could hire a competent proofreader.

Republicans Sought Money They Denounced

GOP For Stimulus After They Were Against It

Mary Kate Cary Right on Sarah Palin

Like Palin, readers should do their homework.

Memo to Sarah Palin: Prepare Next Time

She should know core values like the back of her hand.

GOP Should Beware Obama’s Healthcare Invite

It will be carefully staged to make the president look moderate.

Top Political Nonfiction

A fix to Cilizza’s list.

Why the Tea Party Convention Was a Bad Idea

Right now they have more power as a grassroots movement, that’s bigger than any panel discussion.

Public Opinion

Palin's Hand Notes

Should the GOP's star have been more prepared on major issues?

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.
Make USNews.com your home page.