Saturday, November 21, 2009

Opinion

Robert Schlesinger

Texas Secession? Perry, One Third of Texans Are Wrong: Texas Can't Secede

April 17, 2009 01:15 PM ET | Robert Schlesinger | Permanent Link | Print

By Robert Schlesinger, Thomas Jefferson Street blog

As if their current governor and his predecessor have not done enough damage to Texans' reputation for Constitutional acuity, nearly 1 in 3 Texas voters think that their state has the legal right to secede from the Union, according to a new Rasmussen Poll.

Umm, no.

On the bright side (such as it is), only 1 in 5 Texas voters would actually like to break off from the Union. Fully three quarters of Texas voters are content to remain part of these United States. Gee, thanks.

This discussion was sparked by Texas Gov. Rick Perry's assertion that Texas has the unique right to secede from the U.S. of A. (Side question: Why the quiescence of the hyper-patriotic right? Why are they not demanding that Perry love this country or leave it—and reminding him he can't take his state with him?)

It is of course an old urban legend that since Texas entered the Union as a sovereign Republic, it has reserved the right to reclaim its old status. Horse-hockey.

Two points to consider. First, there's this brief history of the Lone Star State's 1845 entry into the Union, emphasis added:

When all attempts to arrive at a formal annexation treaty failed, the United States Congress passed—after much debate and only a simple majority—a Joint Resolution for Annexing Texas to the United States. Under these terms, Texas would keep both its public lands and its public debt, it would have the power to divide into four additional states "of convenient size" in the future if it so desired, and it would deliver all military, postal, and customs facilities and authority to the United States government. (Neither this joint resolution or the ordinance passed by the Republic of Texas ' Annexation Convention gave Texas the right to secede.)

That paragraph comes from what I can only assume to be an authoritative source on the matter: the Texas State Library and Archives Commission. (Tip of my cowboy hat to an old college pal—from Texas—who posted the link on Facebook.)

Second point: We fought a war over this. Lots of Americans died. The secessionists lost—including the ones in Texas. Secession is no more legal now than it was then.

And while talking about secession undoubtedly plays well among the 3 in 10 Texas voters ill-informed enough to think it's a serious political statement, it also makes the rest of the country (and likely the rest of the state) roll our eyes in bewilderment at the Lone Star Clown.

On Facebook? You can keep up with Thomas Jefferson Street blog postings through Facebook's Networked Blogs.

Tags: Texas

Tools: Share | | Comments (471) | Print

Reader Comments

Declaration of Independence

I agree. This America, today, is not what our men and women died to protect. They died to end tyranny in all forms, and what did we do, we elected a tyrannical president. To the author of this article, who is going to stop a state from secedding? You? America was founded on principles and morals. I have never seen a country so close to the verge of self destruction. I guarrentee you, if a state as a good, sound reason to secede, it will. As for robert, you need take your head out from where the sun don't shine, and realize what is going on. Good night and GOD (not allah) Bless.

Secession

Hello?....Hello? Have you ever read the Declaration of Independence? What a Maroon! Bob, you Dumb Mass, how the hell you think the US got started! I am sure if you had asked the King of England, he would have said it was illegal too....lol. Some people!

Indecency

It is, discouraging comes to mind, but more so pathetic that so many Americans have no idea of the power we as citizens have. Regardless of whether or not a law exists covering secession matters not. The fact of the matter remains, America was founded by patriots who went against laws to ensure life, liberty, and freedom. The colonists did not say, 'oh wait no, British law doesn't let us secede,' then packed up their guns and sat at home. No. They went against the tyrants and wage a war of freedom.

Regardless if anyone of you nay sayers agree with it or not, any state that has enough people wanting to do it can and will secede whether DC likes it or not.

As many have noted, the US military *myself included* are not segregated. I may be a NYer by birth but I reside in AZ as a home state and if a time comes that AZ wants to secede I stand with my state over the corrupt jackasses in DC. I do not believe in an oppressive federal government having control over states and state affairs. If a state wants freedom from oppression it is an American duty to allow that state to do so, if the federal government does not allow secession they only set in stone the fact that they are oppressive and tyrannical but completely dislodging freedom from the American vocabulary.

Secession is the outright action of freedom, and if a state believes it needs to secede to maintain freedom....secession it should be.

Add your thoughts

Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

advertisement

U.S. News Weekly

Subscribe Now

Order the new U.S. News Weekly digital magazine at a special low introductory price!

Robert Schlesinger is a deputy editor at U.S. News and World Report and oversees all opinion editorial content. He is the author of White House Ghosts: Presidents and Their Speechwriters.

advertisement

NEWSLETTER

Sign up today for the latest headlines from U.S. News & World Report delivered to you free.

RSS FEEDS

Personalize your U.S. News with our feeds of blogs and breaking news headlines.

U.S. NEWS MOBILE

U.S. News daily briefings are also available on your mobile device.

People who read this also read ...

Thomas Jefferson St.

Healthcare Deals Hurt Middle Class

Lawmakers' votes should not be based on the government equivalent of a bribe.

It's Not About Race, Jesse

With a changing African-American electorate, Jesse Jackson's comments can be overlooked.

GOP Aims at Moderate Dems

Votes in favor of healthcare might hurt more moderate Democrats.

Sarah Palin's a Quitter and a Whiner

A 20-city book tour and an appearance on Oprah hardly qualify as public service.

The President and the Rogue

They're about as far apart as the states that produced them.

Jobs Take Back Seat to Healthcare

Try as she might, Pelosi can't change the subject that fast.

Women Still Need Mammograms

Is this the start of rationing healthcare coverage?

The Scope of the House Healthcare Abortion Ba

Stupak-Pitts Amendment would be far-reaching.

Cartoon Gallery

Editorial Cartoon

Political Cartoons

Check out our most recent cartoons.

Public Opinion

Should the FCC Regulate Web Fair Play?

The government may step in to prevent traffic-speed shenanigans.

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.
Make USNews.com your home page.