Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Opinion

Peter Roff

Obama Can Act Responsibly on Guantanamo or Please the Liberals, But Not Both

May 20, 2009 10:20 AM ET | Peter Roff | Permanent Link | Print

Reader Comments

Guantanamo Schmantanamo

You call this a "major defeat" for Obama. I don't see it that way at all. First, Guantanamo is a minor issue compared to numerous other issues facing us today (for example, the recession, healthcare costs, Iran, North Korea, and two wars). Obama's selection of the family dog got more coverage than Guantanamo has. Second, the Dems have prevented Obama from closing Guantanamo, at least for now, and this provides Obama with an excuse to keep the place open. He looks good to the world because he has attempted to close it, while he continues to have the option of keeping terrorists there. As an aside, many Americans have irrational fears of keeping terrorists in Federal prisons on the U.S. mainland. The likelihood of escape is virtually nill. I've worked in jails and can tell you they are very secure. No one has ever escaped from a supermax prison, which is where they'd be housed. The likelihood that they would "infect" other inmates with Jihadist anti-American beliefs is minimal. These guys will be outcasts among hardened criminals and will be in grave danger if they are mixed with the general inmate population. Instead, they'd be in solitary conditions 23-hours per day, unable to share their beliefs with other prisoners. Our federal prisons have been housing Islamist terrorists such as the "Blind Shiek" and Ramzi Yousef for years without trouble. We have also held German POW's in U.S. prison camps during WWII with little trouble. We can safely put Islamist terrorists in Federal prisons.

BO Plenty and the "What have you done for me Lately Crowd"

It is refreshing to observe that even the die hard democrats are finally realizing what a horrible blunder it was to elect "Mr Glib", AKA "BO Plenty" (my apologies to Al Capp and "Lil Abner". Since I am 87 years old I don't contemplate being around long enough to see or hear the "Baby Boomers" and all their progeny finally (and grudgingly) admit what a horrible mistake is was to pillory GWB for over 8 years and to now find out that a great deal of what he accomplished in spit of a Liberal congress ws'nt all that bad. Gitmo was a good idea to begin with by putting all that scum in Castro's back yard, and it kept the Muslim hypocrats out of the U.S. We will have to wait for the rest of this 4-year term to get a chance to shut the ignoramuses up...Maybe the rest of this current 4-year term will be enough to get the baby boomers and all their stupidity out of federal offices. You can then watch the east coast and west coast hypocrites stew in their own juice. Obama would'nt make a pimple on George Bushes butt.

Please pray that Sarah Palin 2012 will be victorious

Dear Heavely God the Father, I pray unto Thee that Governor Sarah Palin will be inaugurated the 45th President of the United States of America on January 20, 2013, and reinaugrated President on January 20, 2017. I pray also unto Thee that Governor Sarah Palin will beat Barack Obama in 2012. Above all I pray that Sarah Palin will be the greatest President that the United States of America will have ever had from January 20, 2013 to January 20. 2021. These 3 prayer request I pray unto Thee Thou Heavenly God the Father that Thou wilt answer them both. And I pray this unto Thee in the name of God the Son , the Lord Jesus Christ , Amen

Please vote for Sarah Palin 2012 because of her superior Conservative right wing philosophy

Governor Sarah Palin must beat Barack Obama in 2012 because of her superior conservative right wing philosophy in that she is pro God and Christianity, pro life, pro marriage; pro guns-second amendment, pro low taxes, pro low government spending; pro small government, pro unintrusive government, pro traditional and Judeo Christian values; pro Bible reading and prayer in our public schools, pro Christians schools and private education , pro private and free enterprise; pro military spending, anti arms agreements with Russia, pro creation; pro nuclear, pro conservative supreme court judges, pro American sovereignty; pro capitalism, anti communist, anti socialist; conservative on immigration, and pro constitution. Barack Obama are of the inferior liberal and left wing ideology in that he is against every thing that Governor Sarah Palin is for and he is for every thing that Governor Sarah Palin is against. From 01/20/13 to 01/20/21 Governor Sarah Palin will be a better President than all that all that went before her and after her

Thank You,

JohnWarren

GITMO & Torture

This is totally Much Ado About Nothing! The object of interrogation is to obtain information. You get information by creating fear in the one being interrogated. What is feared may be real or imagined.

Torture has, thru the ages, meant physical violence- beatings, burning, throttling, thumbscrews, The Iron Maiden, electrical shocks, etc. Fear can be caused without these if strong physical uncomfortableness can be induced or introduced making one believe that more & worse is coming. That is not torture. It may be fear of torture, two different things. What our men experienced in the Hanoi Hylton was torture.

If humiliating and making uncomfortable and causing fear in someone can cause one to sing like a canary in order to save us from a disaster, let us do it and stop fiddlefarting around with dumb concepts and thoughtless softhearted

brainlessness.

GITMO & Torture

This is totally Much Ado About Nothing! The object of interrogation is to obtain information. You get information by creating fear in the one being interrogated. What is feared may be real or imagined.

Torture has, thru the ages, meant physical violence- beatings, burning, throttling, thumbscrews, The Iron Maiden, electrical shocks, etc. Fear can be caused without these if strong physical uncomfortableness can be induced or introduced making one believe that more & worse is coming. That is not torture. It may be fear of torture, two different things. What our men experienced in the Hanoi Hylton was torture.

If humiliating and making uncomfortable and causing fear in someone can cause one to sing like a canary in order to save us from a disaster, let us do it and stop fiddlefarting around with dumb concepts and thoughtless softhearted

brainlessness.

Send them to Texas

Where they can be tried, convicted and fried.

The preactice of torture is only for religious sects that exorcise demons from their children.

If this seems cynical, you explain it your way.

Responsible? Don't make me laugh

I love how acting responsibly is described as conservative, since it was Republicans who got us into every single mess we are currently facing, including Guantanamo. Yeah. Responsible my ass. I seriously hope the arrogant bastards aren't smiling about anything right now, and if they are, they deserve a good kick in the nuts.

gaumtonama bay detainees what to do with them

send them back to there own countries&let there people put them behind bars we have enough trouble in the USA let alone worrying about them. i am sure everyone feels the same way.

Gitmo

It seems to me that if the left wants the terrorists brought to the U.S.,they ought to go to one of the following -

1. Washington, D.C.

2. Pelosi's San Francisco

3. Reid's Las Vegas

4. Durbin and Obama's Chicago

5. Biden's Wilmington

I propose that the citizens of these 5 fine cities hold a vote and the location that has the highest approval rating receive the detainees. What could be fairer? They could hold a ticker tape parade.

Add your thoughts

All comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.
U.S. News Weekly

Subscribe Now

Order the new U.S. News Weekly digital magazine at a special low introductory price!

Peter Roff is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report. A former senior political writer for United Press International, he is currently a senior fellow at the Institute for Liberty and at Let Freedom Ring, a non-partisan public policy organization. His writing has also appeared on Fox News' Fox Forum.

advertisement

NEWSLETTER

Sign up today for the latest headlines from U.S. News & World Report delivered to you free.

RSS FEEDS

Personalize your U.S. News with our feeds of blogs and breaking news headlines.

U.S. NEWS MOBILE

U.S. News daily briefings are also available on your mobile device.

People who read this also read ...

Thomas Jefferson St.

Turkey Tax

Uncle Sam is joining in on your Thanksgiving dinner.

Ideological Labels Just Don't Fit

Hard-liners don't understand that some of us don't toe an ideological line.

A Decade in Biased Review

How well does the video sum up the last decade?

GOPers Push European-Style Litmus Tests

Some RNC members want strict party platforms. Why do they hate America?

Can Conservative Carly Fiorina Carry Cali?

Ronald Reagan's state is now one of the most liberal in the nation.

Opinions Clash on Wars in Iran, Afghanistan

Fewer favor the effort in Afghanistan, support rises for hostilities against Iran's nuclear program.

Bennet's Senate Seat Is Already at Risk

His vote on healthcare would be less a case of political martyrdom than it may seem.

Bush Airport Reflects Its Namesake

Could Houston's Bush Intercontinental airport be number one because of its name?

Cartoon Gallery

Editorial Cartoon

Political Cartoons

Check out our most recent cartoons.

Public Opinion

Should the GOP Have a Litmus Test?

Should the RNC exclude politicians who don't match the party's platform?

advertisement

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.
Make USNews.com your home page.