Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Opinion

Tennessee Walking Horse Torture Continues: More Soring Injuries Than Ever Come to Light

September 22, 2008 04:35 PM ET | Permanent Link | Print

To all who've visited my blog before to read my coverage of Tennessee walking horse mistreatment, unfortunately the abuse (by some, not all trainers) continues. This year's so-called Celebration produced a higher number of incidents of abuse by soring than last year's event. That does not mean there is more abuse taking place. It could just mean the more light shining on this formerly secretive industry (secretive for obvious reasons—because some trainers and owners are torturing animals), the less abusers are able to hide in the shadows.

The Chattanooga Times Free Press's Pam Sohn has this heart-rending account of a woman who was forced to put down her Tennessee Walker because of injuries inflicted by a cruel prior owner, coupled with an account of violations by trainers and riders at this year's event:

Charlotte Stolz has spent the week mourning one of her best friends.

Her horse, Soldier, a Tennessee walking horse she tried to rehabilitate from old soring injuries sustained before she bought him, finally succumbed to too many years of abuse. He had to be put down last weekend, she said.

"My heart is broken. I lost a best friend, and I hate that he had to go through that. I want people to know this is wrong," the Hixson resident said.

Soldier's death came just about a week after the 70th Tennessee Walking Horse Celebration ended with more violations of Horse Protection Act this year than last.

Reports posted online by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which enforces the 38-year-old Horse Protection Act, show 187 horses and their trainers were cited with violations related to soring in this year's Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration in Shelbyville, Tenn. Soring is a banned training practice using pain-causing chemicals, cuts, or foreign objects deliberately lodged in hoof pads and shoes to achieve the "big lick" exaggerated show ring movement of some horses in the multimillion-dollar walking horse industry headquartered in Tennessee.

USDA records show there were 2,744 entries in the most recent 11-day Shelbyville event that ended on Aug. 30. The USDA inspected 693 horses while industry officials certified by USDA inspected the remainder.

Last year, Celebration entrants tallied 104 violations, and in 2006, 10 horses were disqualified in the final championship competition. With only three horses left in the ring, the 68th Celebration ended with no champion crowned."

Is it good news or bad that more violators are being charged? It could just mean more violators are coming into public view. The more publicity the practice of soring receives, the closer we are to wiping it off the face of the Earth. That will be a great day.

Tags: Georgia | Tennessee | animals | USDA | horses

Tools: Share | | Comments (46) | Print

Reader Comments

support the tennessee walker

i own and show tennessee walking horses. i know and understand many of the USDA laws, and my horses are also NOT sored. it is ridiculous to sore a horse just to win.

there are several sides to this so called abuse. one immediatley hears about the general public's opinion. a person from the city who knows nothing about horses sees one scarred TWH and immediatly assumes all are like that, or they may see a padded performance horse and call it abuse. they also do not understand that not all TWH are "abused" to be able to walk that way. there is a science behind it, as well as many laws regarding height of pads and amount of weights used. so there is the general population vs the horse society. but inside the horse industry, there is a divison. there are the big time trainers who do sore horses to gain the bigger points and money. more wins equals not only more money for the trainer, but more publicity and therefore more horses sent to his barn to be trained. therefore, these people are totally against all the new laws because they are getting hurt by it. but what about the other people in the industry? ones like myself. we are against soring completely, and win with natural training. we follow all rules, and do not sore. but we are against some laws. such as the strictness on the scar rule. the scar rule is where a USDA DQP inspects the horse for scars from chemical soring. but they dont just count simple scars as you would think, they count callouses to. now here is where the problem comes in, a 16 yr old TWH may have calluses from working hard for so many years, same as a 50 yr old man, so according to the scar rule, a 50 yr old man must retire because of calluses. this is absurd. calluses are not scars. and there is a way to tell. they do look similar, but not the same. and still there are more problems with the USDAs laws. one is hoof testing. if a DQP is not properly trained, they could easily break a horses hoof bar with hoof testing, crippling the horse for the rest of the season. One last controversial thing is this new chemical "sniffer". it was introduced not to long ago. its purpose is to "sniff" out chemicals used for soring. though this sounds like a great idea, it has its flaws. what if a trainer leads the horse across the parking lot, on the way to inspection. there is a chance that the hoofs will pick up diesel. then the sniffer is used and the trainer gets a ticket for using diesel for soring, even though he didnt. these things need to be fixed. Therefore, i stand in the middle. the general public does not have the knowledge to judge, but the trainers have no right to abuse the horse. the government needs to fix the flaws in the system before continuing on. the industry is slowly going down because of the USDA. help is needed. during the winter, before the season starts again in the spring, many things need to change, or else this situation will become worse.

tennessee walkers

my sister has raised walkers for years and would never abuse her animals in such a way-I agree that those people and Mike Vick have much in common. but,once again, it is the people who buy these animals and judge these animals that are to blame the most-for without high scores from judges it would cease to be-what wins is what gets done-so go to the root of this problem-the judges! when scoring changes so will the abuse- what do you judges have to say?

abuse of horses

I attended the walker show in shelbyville tenn. there needs to be more done to help the horses from being misused ,they can not walk natural becouse of the high front feet their back quartes or damamaged .thes people are no better than mike vick.and should be locked up for while .

Add your thoughts

Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

advertisement

U.S. News Weekly

Subscribe Now

Order the new U.S. News Weekly digital magazine at a special low introductory price!

About Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report and hosts PBS's weekly news analysis program, To the Contrary with Bonnie Erbe. She also writes a weekly syndicated newspaper column for Scripps Howard News Service.

advertisement

NEWSLETTER

Sign up today for the latest headlines from U.S. News & World Report delivered to you free.

RSS FEEDS

Personalize your U.S. News with our feeds of blogs and breaking news headlines.

U.S. NEWS MOBILE

U.S. News daily briefings are also available on your mobile device.

FAVORITES

People who read this also read ...

Thomas Jefferson St.

Alan Simpson on Guns and Jail for Kids

A bit of context for the Supreme Court hearings.

Congressional Term Limits

The introduced amendment would limit the amount of permanent politicians.

Google's Christmas Gift

Try it for free ... right up until you can’t give it up.

Recess Politics and Healthcare

Pelosi needed her votes before Veterans' Day break.

No More in Afghanistan

Don't stress the Army any more.

Clinton on Bush and the Berlin Wall

Clinton praises the first Bush for two pivotal decisions to keep peace in Berlin.

Men Have Same Workload As Women At Home

Assuming this will give women a fairer shot in the workplace.

Voters' Top Priority: The Economy

Obama Democrats should stop rushing healthcare reform and address more important issues.

Cartoon Gallery

Editorial Cartoon

Political Cartoons

Check out our most recent cartoons.

Public Opinion

How Can We Best Honor Our Veterans?

How will you remember our nation's veterans?

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.
Make USNews.com your home page.