Rethinking the Iraq Critics
In trying to understand news about the conflicts in Iraq, I work to keep in mind the difference between what we know now about decision-making in World War II and what most Americans knew at the time. From the memoirs and documents published after the war, we've learned how leaders made critical judgments. But at the time, even well-informed journalists could only guess at what was going on behind the scenes.
Today we're only beginning to learn about what went on behind the scenes on Iraq. One important new source is the recently published War and Decision by Douglas Feith, the No. 3 civilian at the Pentagon from 2001 to 2005. Feith quotes extensively from unpublished documents and contemporary memorandums, just as in the late 1940s Robert Sherwood did in Roosevelt and Hopkins and Winston Churchill did in his World War II histories. The picture Feith paints is at considerable variance from the narratives with which we've become familiar.
...continue reading.Tags: Iraq | Iraq war (2003-)
Tools:
Share
|
| Comments (24)
Clinton and Obama's Super Tuesday in Indiana and North Carolina
Corrected on 5/9/08: Due to a posting error, the column titles on the chart were reversed.
The original Super Tuesday, in the 1988 cycle, was engineered by southern and moderate Democrats with the intention of securing the nomination for a moderate southern candidate in a flurry of southern primaries. It worked that year, but for the other party: George H. W. Bush, after his defining victory in South Carolina (scheduled for the Saturday before Super Tuesday by Lee Atwater), swept the South and won the Republican nomination, while on the Democratic side, Al Gore's five primary wins in the South were matched by Jesse Jackson's five, and Michael Dukakis, winning Florida and Texas, went on to win the party's nomination.
This year, the Republican nomination was effectively settled on Super Tuesday, when John McCain's narrow but decisive wins in several states, together with the party's winner-take-all delegate allocation rules, enabled him to build up an insurmountably big delegate lead over Mitt Romney. Mike Huckabee stayed in the race, but obviously had no chance to win; he and McCain traded compliments, and on subsequent election nights Huckabee delivered gracious concession speeches and McCain delivered victory statements aimed at the general electorate. It served both candidates' interests to pretend that there was still a real contest, and Huckabee actually won the Kansas caucus and was competitive in the Virginia primary during this period. But everyone knew McCain was going to be the party's nominee, and treated him accordingly.
...continue reading.Tags: Indiana | North Carolina | Democrats | presidential election 2008 | primaries | Barack Obama | Hillary Clinton
Tools:
Share
|
| Comments (54)
London Elects Conservative Boris Johnson Mayor
The official results show what Friday's papers were predicting: Conservative Boris Johnson has unseated Labor Mayor Ken Livingstone in London. In the multiparty election, Johnson led in first-choice votes 43 percent to 37 percent. Under the rules, the second-choice votes of those who did not vote for either of the first two candidates are added to their totals. This slightly reduced Johnson's margin: Expressed as a percentage of total first- and second-choice votes for the top two candidates, Johnson won 53 percent to 47 percent. By way of comparison, Livingstone led Conservative Steven Norris by 36 percent to 28 percent in first-choice votes in 2004. This map shows the results in each of London's 14 assembly districts. Conservatives elected Assembly members in eight districts, Labor in six.
Regionally, there are some interesting patterns; I'll give Johnson's percentage of the two-candidate first- and second-choice votes in each. Livingston's strongest areas were City and East (37 percent), Southwark and Lambeth (37 percent), and North East (38 percent). These contain many of the historical slums and public housing estates of London. There's been some gentrification in the City and East, between the City and the Docklands, as financial services professionals upgrade old houses or move into spanking-new flats near their places of work. But there are also a lot of Muslim immigrants in some of these areas. The only other district in which Livingstone won an appreciable majority was Greenwich and Lewisham (44 percent), which is mostly low income.
...continue reading.Tags: election results | London
Tools:
Share
|
| Comments (4)
Voters Skeptical of Obama's Outrage With Wright
Will Barack Obama's longtime connection to the Rev. Jeremiah Wright continue to hurt him? Evidence that it will comes from pollster Scott Rasmussen, who finds that only 30 percent of likely voters say Obama denounced Wright because he was outraged, while 58 percent believe he denounced him for political convenience. Only 33 percent believe Obama was surprised by Wright's statements at the National Press Club, while 52 percent say he was not surprised. Some 26 percent say it's very likely that Obama "shares some of Pastor Wright's controversial views about the United States" and 56 percent say it's somewhat likely he does. Only 7 percent of voters and 12 percent of black voters say they share those views. Ouch! These results are more adverse than I would have expected.
Tags: presidential election 2008 | voters | Barack Obama | Rasmussen Report | Jeremiah Wright
Tools:
Share
|
| Comments (11)
Center-Right Candidates Take European Capitals
Well, it's not quite a trend. But the victory of center-right candidate Gianni Alemanno in Rome last weekend has apparently been followed up by a victory for Conservative Party candidate Boris Johnson in London. Rome had been governed by center-left mayors since 1993; London has had an elected mayor for only eight years, and until this year no Conservative candidate was a serious contender. The London results are not in as I write, but you can find them at this website.
Both new mayors are colorful characters. Alemanno is routinely described as a "former neo-fascist"; he was a member of the Alleanza Nazionale and its predecessor the MSI. But he is no more of a totalitarian than his predecessor as mayor of Rome Walter Veltroni—the candidate of the center-left coalition that lost to Silvio Berlusconi's center-right in the April 13-14 elections—who was a member of Italy's old Communist Party. Both are now solidly respectable democratic politicians. Johnson has been busy as a member of Parliament and sometime editor of the Spectator from 1999 to 2005 and columnist in the Telegraph. His columns were often humorous and politically incorrect. But then the two-term incumbent mayor he has apparently ousted, Ken Livingstone, was politically incorrect in different ways: He lavished praise on Hugo Chávez and Fidel Castro and heaped obloquy on the United States. Livingstone nonetheless has had an interesting record as mayor, putting into place congestion pricing in central London (it costs you £8—$15.87—to drive over the line), encouraging commercial development, and preparing for the 2012 Olympics.
...continue reading.Tags: Europe | election results | London
Tools:
Share
|
| Comments (0)
Obama Is Throwing Wright Under the Bus
On Monday, the Rev. Jeremiah Wright spoke at the National Press Club in Washington, with nationwide reverberations. On Tuesday, Barack Obama denounced Wright and his statements. Judging from the talk I've been hearing from Democratic insiders since Wright's Monday speech, Obama did what he had to do. But the problem remains. Obama has now taken two positions on Wright. March 13: No, I cannot disown him. April 29: Yes, I can. Left still unanswered is the question: How can the man we heard deliver that speech in July 2004 about what unites us—in which his strongest line was "in the blue states we worship an awesome God"—how could that Barack Obama have attended the church of that Rev. Jeremiah Wright for 20 years? And not just attended: He and his wife contributed more than $20,000 to the church. It just doesn't add up. It undercuts Obama's very appealing theme of bridging divisions in our society.
I think this is going to be a continuing problem for Obama. As I suggested several weeks ago, it threatens especially to dampen the support Obama has won from young voters—the millennial generation. He has brought them out in great and unexpected numbers to vote for him in primaries and caucuses. It's not clear he will be able to do that in the general election—and the argument that he can has been one that has had weight with many Democratic superdelegates.
...continue reading.Tags: presidential election 2008 | Barack Obama | Jeremiah Wright
Tools:
Share
|
| Comments (28)
Pennsylvania Primary Results by Congressional District
Here are the Pennsylvania primary results by congressional district. Barack Obama carried two districts, the Philadelphia-based First and Second, by wide margins and three others—the suburban Sixth, the Lancaster-based 16th, and the central Pittsburgh 14th—by narrow margins. Hillary Clinton carried the other 14 districts.
Tags: presidential election 2008 | primaries | Barack Obama | Hillary Clinton | Pennsylvania
Tools:
Share
|
| Comments (1)
About the Barone Blog
advertisement
OTHER ARTICLES FROM THE MICHAEL BARONE BLOG
- May 2008 (5)
- April 2008 (23)
- March 2008 (21)
- February 2008 (15)
- January 2008 (18)
- December 2007 (11)
- November 2007 (6)
- October 2007 (11)
- September 2007 (5)
- August 2007 (11)
- July 2007 (11)
- June 2007 (12)
- May 2007 (14)
- April 2007 (21)
- March 2007 (24)
- February 2007 (17)
- January 2007 (19)
- December 2006 (14)
- November 2006 (23)
- October 2006 (15)
- September 2006 (19)
- August 2006 (24)
- July 2006 (14)
- June 2006 (45)
- May 2006 (26)
- April 2006 (31)
- March 2006 (38)
- February 2006 (32)
- January 2006 (40)
- December 2005 (27)
- November 2005 (44)
- October 2005 (23)
- September 2005 (50)
- August 2005 (40)
