Monday, November 9, 2009

Opinion

Is the Public Option the Key to Healthcare Reform?

HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius and Sen. Mike Enzi debate healthcare reform in the latest U.S. News Weekly

Posted July 2, 2009

Backers of a public option for health insurance say it would help control costs and guarantee coverage for all. Opponents insist that a government-run plan would put private insurers out of business, leaving Americans with only one choice: socialized care. Can the public option work? What would work better? Post your thoughts, and don't forget to check out the debate in the latest U.S. News Weekly.

Previously: Is McCain Guilty Over Picking Palin?

Take our poll: Is the public option the key to healthcare reform?

Reader Comments

member-owned health care cooperatives

If we had an alternative option of health care cooperatives that operated more like credit unions (i.e., for the benefit of the subscribers and not for the benefit of investors), that would help minimize the costs. If subscribers all voted on rule changes and rate changes, it would provide transparency and a sense of empowerment and personal responsibility to the subscribers. It might be possible for the government to offer subsidy packages to enable people with low incomes to subscribe. The transparency and responsibility involved in such a system would give everyone an appreciation for what health care really costs and it would make it obvious that we can't have everything we want. The subscribers would have to choose how much to charge themselves and what they were willing to cover. That would make everyone highly motivated to invest in prevention and it would make everyone eager to drive down the overhead. Without transparency and responsibility, we have a system where people think that they can demand more and more, pay less, and not make much effort to take better care of themselves.

healthcare options

I don't want anything for "free", just something affordable. I lost my insurance several years ago ( my individual plan was cancelled after i used it) and have been in a nightmare ever since. The cheapest insurance I can get comes in over $800 a month. I am 59, in generally good health, working two jobs, and still can't afford to pay that. If Obama gets this through, and it is an affordable option for those of us without employer coverage, I will be first in line next election. HELP!!!!

Public Health

Good Lord! I'm a lifelong Republican, yet I have favored not just a "Public Option", but full National Medicine, since living in Europe 40 years ago. We are the ONLY country in the civilized world WITHOUT National Health Care. It should be the first purpose of government, well above military and education. We are a primitive nation, living in the past, on this issue.

PUBLIC health would be far cheaper than the current "theft option". Middlemen steal 33% of what we "spend on health". Transaction costs in Europe are just 2%! Single payer, computerized health records, the 21st Century "option".

We cover everybody one way or the other. Now, they just go to the back door of the hospital. It would be cheaper to bring the uninsured in through the front door. My business clients would return to a competitive position in the international markets, and generate new profits, without being burdened by "health care benefits". Who thought this up anyway? Why would BUSINESS be responsible for health, not government? Why not the CHURCH? Why not FAMILY? What a goofy system we have, not logical, not even sane.

Force me to buy insurance? That sounds like a tax to me. Forced profits for a non-productive insurance industry.

While we are at it, simplifying medical, why don't we go to a value added tax system, like so many others?

Add your thoughts

Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

advertisement

Crossword Puzzle

Do You Like Crosswords?

We've added a new feature to our weekly digital magazine: an exclusive crossword puzzle!

advertisement

Cartoon Gallery

Editorial Cartoon

Political Cartoons

Check out our most recent cartoons.

Washington Book Club

Foreign Policy by Contractor

Allison Stanger discusses One Nation Under Contract.

What the 2009 Elections Tell Us About 2010

By Tom Davis

Seven lessons the parties need to learn from Tuesday's races.

The 2009 off-year elections in Virginia, New Jersey, and New York's 23d Congressional District offer a small snapshot of the current views and motivations of the American electorate. While there may be a desire to extrapolate the events of Nov. 3, 2009 into a prediction of what will happen on Nov. 2, 2010, that is impossible.

Healthcare Cartoon Gallery

Editorial Cartoon

We've assembled some of the best editorial cartoons on the healthcare debate. Check them out.

Thomas Jefferson St.

Voters' Top Priority: The Economy

Obama Democrats should stop rushing healthcare reform and address more important issues.

H1N1 Vaccine for Wall Street?

Another example of what's wrong with government run healthcare.

Healthcare Vote Delays a Bad Sign for Dems

Expect more waiting, and arm twisting, as vulnerable reps take the hint from voters.

Americans Want Jobs, Not Healthcare Reform

As the unemployment rate reaches double digits, the public makes its preference known.

California Candidates' Poor Voting Record

Couldn't Carly Fiorina and Meg Whitman have put a note in their BlackBerrys about voting?

Pelosi Cracks the Whip on Moderates

She's using fear of payback to push middle-of-the-road Democrats to vote for the House bill.

A Dollar a Day to Keep the Babies Away

North Carolina program aiding at-risk kids needs to go nationwide.

The New V Takes Swipes at Both Sides

Are they sniping at Obama? Sure? Bush too.

Your Photos

President Barack Obama speaks about combat troop level reductions in Iraq as he addresses military personnel at Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune.

Obama in Your Town

Has the president visited your town? Send your photos to obamaphotos@usnews.com, and we'll post our favorites online.

Courtesy Greg Meinert

Thousands cheer as Obama becomes the 44th president.

Your Inauguration Photos

Thanks for sending us such great shots from this historic event.


A baby kissing an Obama poster for Washington Whispers.

Your Campaign Photos

We asked to see your personal election pictures and you delivered.

advertisement

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.
Make USNews.com your home page.