Saturday, November 21, 2009

Opinion

Healthcare Reform Means Taking "No" for an Answer

Saying yes to every new drug, device, or test doesn't necessarily lead to better health

Posted June 23, 2009

Jessie Gruman is president of the Center for the Advancement of Health.

Something's gotta give in healthcare. As individuals, we can't just go on saying "yes" to every drug, device, test, or intervention that might work. And as a nation, we can't just allow our health bill to continue to climb, bankrupting sick patients and our economy.

The Obama administration promised healthcare reform and all the interest groups—health professionals, drug and device manufacturers, hospitals, the insurance industry, and patient advocates—are at the table. There is broad agreement that something has to change. And change probably requires saying "no" to some things.

Discussions of reform have begun to encounter resistance: While everyone agrees that limits must be set, each party thinks it's the others who should be reined in.

The public is no different. Rather than thinking that reform means increasing limits, we think of it as increasing opportunities: easier access to affordable healthcare services and doctors we can trust to make good use of the best tests and drugs and devices to keep us free of pain and fully engaged in our lives. Far too few of us realize that less care is often better care and we are thus understandably reluctant to say "no" to recommended tests or procedures of limited value.

Reformers and policy experts interested in reducing costs and improving care have some ideas about what we should say "no" to: treatments that have not been shown to work, doctors who err, and hospitals with poor safety records. "No" to expensive new tests and drugs that are no more effective than older, cheaper ones. "No" to extra tests and services that won't improve our health and the quality of our lives.

But a recent Kaiser Family Foundation poll demonstrates that whether the public will agree to "just say no" depends upon who asks.

It found, for example, that we trust our doctor to tell us what tests and treatments we need, but not our health plan or the government. We don't think there is a significant difference in competence among the doctors who treat us and we are more likely to rely on the experience of friends and family over objective ratings of doctors and hospitals. We're convinced that under-use (caused by penny-pinching health plans) is a bigger problem than the overuse of services. And we believe we are already paying too much for care, which we think is costly due to the excessive profits of insurance and drug companies.

Current reform proposals call for everyone—health plans, drug and device manufacturers, physicians, nurses, hospitals, and yes, the public, sick and well—to recognize and accept new limitations.

And so, alas, healthcare reform is about "no," even for us.

As voters, we will determine the success or defeat of this year's reform efforts. But let's not kid ourselves: Our choice is not between unlimited access to all the healthcare we think we need and draconian government intervention. Rather, we either learn to accept explicit, evidence-based limitations in plans, providers, and treatments, or we continue to accept limitations to care based on de facto rationing of access (growing numbers of uninsured, under-insured, and medically inspired bankruptcy) and treatment (increasingly constrained benefits packages that restrict what treatments they will cover)—accompanied by steadily increasing costs.

We have to say "no" to one of these options. Something's gotta give. Which "no" is it going to be?

Reader Comments

Just tell us what it is going to cost....

I think most people would be more rational about accepting health care changes if a clear cost/benefit was laid out instead of all the political manipulations and attempts to make bad look good and good bad. Just be honest and tell us how much we are going to have to pay for it!

A Concerned Citizen

"Why should they worry if we get sick? They don't pay the bill. We do - and sometimes we get destitute in doing so, and some of us die. Not their problem."-Joan

Your talking about the food industry, but what about our federal government? They are not paying for this system either, we are! So why should they care or worry if we get sick...they don't pay the bill. We do and "sometimes we get destitute in doing so, and some of us die"...again, wouldn't be their problem either. It is also a nice way to smuggle in more of our tax dollars and make excuses for raising your tax dollars each and every year. You know how politicians are especially the ones we have in Congress right now. They'll make every excuse to increase or create a new tax while in the mean time, stealing your tax dollars through the little loop holes established through legislation, which is never read by the American people. I am for reform and I do believe that change is necessary, but is the Health care reform Democrats are proposing in Congress the right change? Thats my question and is it the only change or option or way? Absolutely not. There are many proposals right now. I am not looking for a band aid fix. This health care reform will leave many Americans vulnerable. It will eliminate competition and choice, and dictate American's decisions on issues that were once considered personal and private. It will force about 70% of Americans who are already insured to leave their doctors (some of whom they've had for many years) or least potentially will force them to. Also, it will cost triple the amount to maintain while the quality of your health care will decrease. Your putting the power of your health into the hands a very few and allowing them to make the decisions for you. While your taxes dollars (which you can guarantee will increase to ridiculous amounts as the years progress) are paying for the whole thing. Remember, who ever holds your money, controls your country. If government is generating billions of your tax dollars every year, they sure as hell are the ones who will be calling the shots and establishing and implementing the policies. I've heard some other proposals that are sounding a lot better than Obamas. I wonder why they are not getting any air time? I am deeply concerned. Please do not be fooled by the illusion. It's a bad fix for a deeply hurting America.

Concerned Citizen

"Why should they worry if we get sick? They don't pay the bill. We do - and sometimes we get destitute in doing so, and some of us die. Not their problem."-Joan

Your talking about the food industry, but what about our federal government? They are not paying for this system either, we are! So why should they care or worry if we get sick...they don't pay the bill. We do and "sometimes we get destitute in doing so, and some of us die"...again, wouldn't be their problem either. It is also a nice way to smuggle in more of our tax dollars and make excuses for raising your tax dollars each and every year. You know how politicians are especially the ones we have in Congress right now. They'll make every excuse to increase or create a new tax while in the mean time, stealing your tax dollars through the little loop holes established through legislation, which is never read by the American people. I am for reform and I do believe that change is necessary, but is the Health care reform Democrats are proposing in Congress the right change? Thats my question and is it the only change or option or way? Absolutely not. There are many proposals right now. I am not looking for a band aid fix. This health care reform will leave many Americans vulnerable. It will eliminate competition and choice, and dictate American's decisions on issues that were once considered personal and private. It will force about 70% of Americans who are already insured to leave their doctors (some of whom they've had for many years) or least potentially will force them to. Also, it will cost triple the amount to maintain while the quality of your health care will decrease. Your putting the power of your health into the hands a very few and allowing them to make the decisions for you. While your taxes dollars (which you can guarantee will increase to ridiculous amounts as the years progress) are paying for the whole thing. Remember, who ever holds your money, controls your country. If government is generating billions of your tax dollars every year, they sure as hell are the ones who will be calling the shots and establishing and implementing the policies. I've heard some other proposals that are sounding a lot better than Obamas. I wonder why they are not getting any air time? I am deeply concerned. Please do not be fooled by the illusion. It's a bad fix for a deeply hurting America.

Add your thoughts

Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

advertisement

Crossword Puzzle

Do You Like Crosswords?

We've added a new feature to our weekly digital magazine: an exclusive crossword puzzle!

advertisement

Cartoon Gallery

Editorial Cartoon

Political Cartoons

Check out our most recent cartoons.

Mary Kate Cary

Mary Kate Cary

The GOP Should Reach Out to Women

The male-dominated party just doesn't understand what women want.

Mort Zuckerman

Mort Zuckerman

For Israel, Hints of Palestinian Progress

As Palestinians start taking control of criminal gangs and terrorists, peace looks possible.

Palin Cartoon Gallery

Editorial Cartoon

We've assembled some of the best editorial cartoons on Sarah Palin. Check them out.

Thomas Jefferson St.

Healthcare Deals Hurt Middle Class

Lawmakers' votes should not be based on the government equivalent of a bribe.

It's Not About Race, Jesse

With a changing African-American electorate, Jesse Jackson's comments can be overlooked.

GOP Aims at Moderate Dems

Votes in favor of healthcare might hurt more moderate Democrats.

Sarah Palin's a Quitter and a Whiner

A 20-city book tour and an appearance on Oprah hardly qualify as public service.

The President and the Rogue

They're about as far apart as the states that produced them.

Jobs Take Back Seat to Healthcare

Try as she might, Pelosi can't change the subject that fast.

Women Still Need Mammograms

Is this the start of rationing healthcare coverage?

The Scope of the House Healthcare Abortion Ba

Stupak-Pitts Amendment would be far-reaching.

Your Photos

President Barack Obama speaks about combat troop level reductions in Iraq as he addresses military personnel at Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune.

Obama in Your Town

Has the president visited your town? Send your photos to obamaphotos@usnews.com, and we'll post our favorites online.

Courtesy Greg Meinert

Thousands cheer as Obama becomes the 44th president.

Your Inauguration Photos

Thanks for sending us such great shots from this historic event.


A baby kissing an Obama poster for Washington Whispers.

Your Campaign Photos

We asked to see your personal election pictures and you delivered.

Public Opinion

Should the FCC Regulate Web Fair Play?

The government may step in to prevent traffic-speed shenanigans.

advertisement

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.
Make USNews.com your home page.