Thursday, November 26, 2009

Opinion

Conservatives Cautious on Criticizing Sotomayor, Liberals Taunt, 'I Dare Ya!'

Bloggers on Sonia Sotomayor, North Korea, gay marriage in California, and healthcare

Posted May 27, 2009

Our daily look at stories and topics that are lighting up the Internets:

The Soto-Storm

"Okay, we're all interested in President Obama's Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor," writes Chris Rovzar in this nice roundup. "But today it's just getting to feel like too much. Not because democracy in action is ever boring, but because the media has lost its head." That being said, bloggers have had a day to think the Sotomayor appointment over, and the battle lines are forming. As per yesterday, let's look at reactions from both sides of the political spectrum. First up: conservatives. Damon Root is concerned: "On the hot-button issues of affirmative action and Second Amendment rights, her record suggests a decidedly illiberal vision of constitutional law." Alex Knepper writes that "Sotomayor's nomination is a unique opportunity for the conservative movement to rally all of its factions together," but calling her a racist for saying the following is not the way to go: "I would hope that a wise Latina woman, with the richness of her experiences, would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn't lived that life." Conservative Ed Morrissey thinks the GOP can win by using the competence argument. And Philip Klein sums up conservative outrage: "The Obama/Sotomayor idea that judges, instead of making impartial rulings based on the law and the Constitution, should base their decisions (at least in part) on their own experiences and ethnic background, is outrageous."

The Liberal Reaction

Most liberals write today less on Sotomayor than on the Republicans' strategy for attacking her. What's a blogpost, after all, if it isn't about "the opposition"? Jay Newton-Small thinks the GOP's plan is to "walk softly and carry a huge magnifying glass." Greg Sargent writes that the reaction from the right is already helping liberals. Democrats, he predicts, will respond by arguing that GOP opposition to Sotomayor "is all about Republican extremism" and not her competence as a judge. David Kurtz concurs: "So far the criticisms of Sonia Sotomayor are much more revealing about her conservative critics than they are about her." In an odd twist, one liberal blogger focuses on the dry subject of what Sotomayor actually thinks. Robert Reich thinks GOP attacks on Sotomayor will end up decimating what's left of the Republican Party: "It's also possible that without much remaining of any moderate view inside their own ranks, Republicans may simply lack the wisdom—dare I call it judiciousness?—to opt for a more sensible strategy."

The Rest of Today's News

Thomas E. Ricks notes that North Korea's acting unusually reckless. Here's a great summary of the NoKo situation that Ricks points his readers to. Looks like John McCain's had a feeling NoKo was up to no good. Liberal Rob Thomas has a big gay chip on his shoulder because of the latest setback to gay marriage in California. The Washington Post's E.J. Dionne pens this piece for The New Republic, in which he looks at how the Obama administration goes about manipulating the media: "The disturbing aspect of Obama's effort to create his new political alignment is that building it requires him to send rather different messages to its component parts. Playing to several audiences at once can lead to awkward moments." And Karen Tumulty singles out one healthcare story that you should read today.

... Meanwhile ...

Russian President Vladimir Putin writes his first magazine column on pink slips... Alas, the F-bomb likely has no home in the workplace... And are you wondering if the recession's over? Check your underpants.

Check out our political cartoons.

  • Print  |
  • Subscribe  |
  • |
  • |
  • Sphere: Related Content

Reader Comments

Sotomayor states the obvious...

Ahhh, Newt...leave it to an old white guy to further alienate the youth and people of color from the Republican party. As a woman of color, Sotomayor has experienced life in a whole different way than a white man. Her comment which was made 8 years ago is not racist, but is merely stating the obvious. In order to rid of society of racism, we need to recognize that racism exists and that historically people of color have needed to work harder than whites for the same opportunities. Hopefully, electing the first black president shows that our society is changing.

Rights accusation of racism shows ignorance

Sotomayor has an impressive resume and is plenty qualified for the job which is why the right is focussing on an out of context comment and sickly trying to deem it racist. This only demonstrates the right's ignorance of white privilege and the true meaning of racism. Racism in society is the unjust discrimination based on race against a group of people who are not in a position of power by a group of a different race who are in a position of power. The key word here is POWER! If the right understood what racism was they would understand that racism against whites rarely happens in our society because whites are still in the majority of power positions in our society. Therefore I think the meaning of Sotomayor's comment is that an educated Latina woman has needed to overcome many more obstacles in her lifetime than a white educated man and therefore has a different perspective and understanding of our society as a whole. The more the right screams racism the more it demonstartes their ignorance of their own white privilege and the more it shows truth in Sotomayor's comment.

Life stories...

For one reason or another, this country focuses on sensational and emotional things rather than objective data. Best example of this can be seen with Sotomayor. While I do not mean to discredit her background, but I have a neat life story too about how I have over come my essential tremors in my hands and my learning disability. Yet my life story does not mean I am qualified to be a plumber or an astronaut. However, according to the media, it means I am qualified to be a Supreme Court Justice just because I have an amazing life story. Come on people! Why don't we start looking at how she makes rulings and what her political views are?

Add your thoughts

Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

advertisement

Crossword Puzzle

Do You Like Crosswords?

We've added a new feature to our weekly digital magazine: an exclusive crossword puzzle!

advertisement

Cartoon Gallery

Editorial Cartoon

Political Cartoons

Check out our most recent cartoons.

Mary Kate Cary

Mary Kate Cary

The GOP Should Reach Out to Women

The male-dominated party just doesn't understand what women want.

Mort Zuckerman

Mort Zuckerman

The Financial System Needs a Careful Cure

Let the Federal Reserve oversee new regulations for finance giants.

Palin Cartoon Gallery

Editorial Cartoon on Sarah Palin

We've assembled some of the best editorial cartoons on Sarah Palin. Check them out.

Thomas Jefferson St.

GOP Can Be Thankful for Strong Polls

But they cannot get complacent.

5 Reasons for a Democratic Thanksgiving

Michael Steele and healthcare reform top the list.

Women Have Say on Health Reform

If it's the year of the women, why are there so few of them?

Turkey Tax

Uncle Sam is joining in on your Thanksgiving dinner.

Ideological Labels Just Don't Fit

Hard-liners don't understand that some of us don't toe an ideological line.

A Decade in Biased Review

How well does the video sum up the last decade?

GOPers Push European-Style Litmus Tests

Some RNC members want strict party platforms. Why do they hate America?

Your Photos

President Barack Obama speaks about combat troop level reductions in Iraq as he addresses military personnel at Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune.

Obama in Your Town

Has the president visited your town? Send your photos to obamaphotos@usnews.com, and we'll post our favorites online.

Courtesy Greg Meinert

Thousands cheer as Obama becomes the 44th president.

Your Inauguration Photos

Thanks for sending us such great shots from this historic event.


A baby kissing an Obama poster for Washington Whispers.

Your Campaign Photos

We asked to see your personal election pictures and you delivered.

Public Opinion

Should the GOP Have a Litmus Test?

Should the RNC exclude politicians who don't match the party's platform?

advertisement

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.
Make USNews.com your home page.