Saturday, October 11, 2008

Opinion

Public Opinion: When Are John McCain and Barack Obama's Flip-flops Not Flip-flops?

Under what circumstances is it OK for presidential candidates to change their positions on an issue?

Posted August 5, 2008

Whether on offshore drilling, Iraq, taxes, or a variety of other issues, changes in the policy positions Sens. Barack Obama and John McCain have held have been criticized in the blogosphere and media as either (depending on your political preference) craven flip-flops or leaderlike evolutions responding to changing circumstances. When is it OK for a politician to change his or her previously held policy position? Post your thoughts below.

Previously: Barack Obama and offshore drilling—a flip-flop or real leadership?

  • Print  |
  • Subscribe  |
  • |
  • |
  • Sphere: Related Content

Reader Comments

flipping isn't always flopping

People grow, they evolve but when a poliician "clarifys" or outright changes his position on a major issue one must ask why. A case in point was John McCain's revamping his immigration plan. In his own words, he "got the nessage", referring to the public outcry against amnesty in any form in favor of border security. Compare that to the Obama switch from "drilling for oil is a gimmick" to "I am open to drilling" within 24 hours. It is still clear that McCain's position on immigration is still based on his belief that the systemic issues need to be addressed but he realized that that goal must follow border security. Obama's about face appears to be more related to polls than to a real empathy with the American voter.

For more on this and other issues, check out nobullnobias.blogspot.com

Dump McCain!!

John McCain is going to get steamrolled on November 4th by an empty suit (Obama), and there is really nothing that McCain can do to iron out the wrinkles in his own already “empty suit”.

I, being someone who will not "pick flies out of sh*t" in my choice for a presidential candidate, neither McCain nor Obama is qualified for our nations' most important job. McCain will have to choose a real dope for his running mate in order to prevent being overshadowed and having his lack of substance revealed.

The best thing that we can do is NOT nominate him at all and choose Ron Paul instead at the GOP convention in September!! Ron Paul is more than qualified, has a plan that will work and will lead our nation honorably. Ron Paul can raise the money, get people excited and has the best chance of beating Obama of all the other Republican candidates. The GOP would be foolish not to nominate Ron Paul! This will also explain why Ron Paul’s “ Rally for the Republic “ will most definitely overshadow John McCain’s presumptive nomination at the dull Republican National Convention down the street.

It's not too late to admit that McCain is a bad choice and to remedy the situation. If no one is excited about McCain now, they surely won't be two months from now. Get the geezer out now so we won't have a 1996 repeat of Bob Dole! McCain can't win if he doesn't have the support of the conservative base and nothing is going to change that, plain and simple! There will not be a last minute reprieve by disgruntled Republicans this time around to save him when most people are finally rejecting the worn-out lesser of two evils argument. If McCain remains as the nominee until November, he will destroy the Republican Party and run its members out to most likely join the Libertarian or Constitution Party, or simply drop out of the voting process all together. This wouldn't necessarily be a bad scenario as long as these people are not continuing to do the same thing that yields the same bad results. John McCain had his opportunity in 2000 and failed, and this is not even the same John McCain as then; but a worn out neocon with nothing to offer. It’s time to “Dump McCain”!!

It depends on why they changed their position

If it's purely for political expediency, then it's a flip-flop. If it's because of changing circumstances, the evolution of the person's thinking or experience, or the need to compromise with opponents to get something done then it is understandable, even if I don't necessarily agree with it.

Add your thoughts

Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

advertisement

Two Takes On...

President Bush and partial quotes from editorials from the Toledo Blade and the Portland Oregonian are seen in this image made from a campaign ad for Democratic presidential nominee, Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass., set to air Monday, Aug. 23, 2004. The commercial is the second Kerry ad responding to Swift Boat Veterans for Truth, a group which questions Kerry's military record. (Kerry-Edwards 2004/AP)

Negative Ads—Good or Bad for the Country?

The country needs them, Dick Morris argues. They hurt society, James Leach says.

Robert Dallek

Portrait of Harry S. Truman

Palin, McCain, Bush...Truman? Nope

Republican attempts to embrace Harry Truman are wildly misguided, historian Robert Dallek writes.

advertisement

Marjorie Margolies

Vice President Al Gore looks on as President Bill Clinton places an '0' on the board showing what the federal deficit will be after unveiling his balanced budget plan during a ceremony at the White House. (Paul J. Richards/AFP/Getty Images)

Recalling Another Tough Vote

Former Rep. Marjorie Margolies recalls the vote that cost her her job—the 1993 Clinton tax package.

Thomas Jefferson St.

Don't Buy the GOP Voter Fraud Talking Points

The Republicans' record on voter fraud is thin.

This Year's Voter Fraud is Democratic

The Democratic candidate's connections to the group raise questions.

The Republican Party's Time Is Up

It's time for the ruling party to reap what it has sowed.

Conservatives Slam Troopergate Story

A "New York Times" story provokes a backlash.

Sarah Palin's Plane Problems

A plane, a plane, my governship for a plane!

Is the McCain-Obama Race Over?

The Thomas Jefferson Street gang has weighed in—now you let us know what you think.

Obama May Not Have Election Locked Up

There are lots of factors that make a Democratic victory uncertain.

Sarah Palin—Feminist or Victim of Sexism?

This is what a feminist looks like? Let's not go there.

A baby kissing an Obama poster for Washington Whispers. Clary Tepper

Send Us Your Campaign Photos

We want to see your personal photos with Barack Obama, John McCain, Joe Biden, and Sarah Palin. Send the best shots of you and the candidates to campaignphotos@usnews.com and we'll post the best on our website over the coming weeks.

Public Opinion

Can McCain Come Back Against Obama?

Obama has a substantial lead in the polls. Is it too much for McCain to overcome?

Blog Buzz

McCain-Palin Crowds Angry, Troopergate Report

Rowdy GOP supporters at McCain-Palin rallies; Palin releases her own Troopergate report.

advertisement

NEWSLETTER

Sign up today for the latest headlines from U.S. News & World Report delivered to you free.

RSS FEEDS

Personalize your U.S. News with our feeds of blogs and breaking news headlines.

U.S. NEWS MOBILE

U.S. News daily briefings are also available on your mobile device.

WIDGETS

Embed exclusive U.S. News headlines, rankings, columns, and blog postings to your Web site, blog, or social network.

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.