Details of IRS Deal With UBS Expected Friday
The government is trying to crack down on Swiss bank accounts and other offshore tax havens
A deal has been reached in principle in the showdown between the Internal Revenue Service and the Swiss banking giant, UBS, over the identity of thousands of U.S. account holders that the feds believe aren't paying their share of taxes. A U.S. district court judge in Florida will hear details of the proposed deal this week, in a civil case which has the potential to undo Swiss traditions of bank secrecy that date to the Middle Ages.
The IRS and the Justice Department say that the 50,000 American account holders have some $14.8 billion squirreled away in secret offshore accounts.
The IRS is seeking to force UBS to disclose the names of U.S taxpayers, who are required to annually report income generated by foreign accounts. Bank secrecy laws in foreign countries help would-be cheats hide those earnings. Both the Swiss government and UBS contend that divulging the information to U.S. authorities would violate Switzerland's strict bank secrecy laws. Releasing the names could also threaten a pillar of the Swiss economy, the tradition of strict secrecy that has made its banks a top repository for global deposits.
Earlier this month, the Swiss government threatened to seize the records of the American clients, rather than allow UBS to violate its laws by handing them over to U.S. officials. The situation sets up a dilemma for the banking giant: If UBS complies with U.S. demands, the bank and its officers could face sanctions and prosecution in Switzerland. On the other hand, not doing so would run the bank afoul of U.S. courts.
As a result, the case has created a diplomatic imbroglio for Barack Obama's administration, which didn't initiate the prosecution but has been as determined as the Bush Justice Department to compel UBS to disclose the information. Cracking down on tax cheats and offshore havens was a campaign issue for Obama and has become a priority for his administration. Even as the case winds through the courts, diplomats in Washington and Bern are frantically trying to come up with a last-minute compromise to head off a legal clash.
The IRS prevailed in the criminal phase of the case, with the aid of former UBS officials who alleged that the company systematically helped wealthy Americans conceal money. In February, as part of a deferred-prosecution agreement ending the criminal prosecution, UBS disclosed to U.S. investigators the names of 250 to 300 American clients whom the bank suspected of tax fraud, an evidentiary standard UBS contends has not been met in the request for the additional names. The company also paid a $780 million fine to avoid criminal prosecution for aiding tax cheats. Last month, a New York toy dealer pleaded guilty to filing false tax returns and concealing more than $8 million in accounts at UBS and a second Swiss bank. He is the third American UBS client since April to plead guilty to filing false returns, according to the Justice Department.
Meanwhile, in anticipation of the case being resolved, hundreds of wealthy Americans are turning themselves in to the IRS, which has offered leniency, though not amnesty, for those who come clean before the end of September. The voluntary disclosure forms also ask cheats to provide detailed descriptions of who may have helped conceal the funds, in turn giving the IRS more ammunition to challenge banks like UBS in court.
Reader Comments
Swiss goverment and banks are in cahoots- pursue this vigorously
It is about time that the US government stop tolerating evasions from the Swiss with their pretention of "purity" and neutrality and confidentiality. They are driven only by pure financial self-interest. Let the US government threaten to close off Swiss banking transactions in New York to any Swiss bank that doesn't comply with its request. There is nothing to motivate a Swiss banker as the mere thought of losing profits. He/she will weigh the loss of "confidentiality" against the loss of access to the international banking world.
Further, it is imperative to pursue the tax evaders to the full extent of the law and not sugarcoat it with discounts for compliance. Why should the tax evasion of long record be rewarded? Why give them a free ride? Our Western society at its best has incorporated the teachings of the Bible into its constitutions: "Justice, justice, shall you pursue" (Deuteronomy 16:20)and "do not favor the person of the mighty" (Leviticus 19:15).
But even more importantly, the US government should comprehensively reevaluate its taxing laws which are designed to favor the wealthy. How so? Because through their financial resources they influence the political leaders in the laws that are enacted. It is time to have not only just laws but righteous ones. Legality and decency are not the same. The failure to have righteous laws makes the less wealthy cynical and gives them the feeling of being suckers in holding to the law. Faith in government is attained when it is seen to be impartial and fair. Who doubts in our present taxing circumstance that the laws favor the rich who of course stay within its bounds with all the lawyers and business managers they can afford. The Swiss banking thing is only a beginning of the readjustment that must be vigorously undertaken.
Let's not see the Republicans win the next election with the slogan: "Yes we can' he said, but he didn't!"
Prosecution
I think the US should prosecute these evaders ferociously and confiscate ALL the money they sent abroad in secret. And then fine them in addition and imprison them.
Treasury Men
A few years ago I inquired about opening an account in a foreign bank abroad. When they asked my nationality, and found I was a US Citizen, they refused to open the account without me disclosing my social security number. I should not have been surprised at the long arm of the US Treasury, and at the time, I was annoyed. However, on reflection, I see that average people like me don't have the opportunity to hide money, whereas wealthy people do, and now I am in favor of the US Government chasing these cheats until they comply with US law. Unless they are willing to renounce their citizenship, they should always have to look over their shoulders. Seems like a few of them are already finding religion. What a pleasant thought that we should balance the budget with the full participation of these wealthy rapscallions.
advertisement









