Saturday, October 11, 2008

Nation

Benedict Arnold: A Traitor, but Once a Patriot

The one-time war hero chose a path of betrayal after becoming disillusioned with the cause

Posted June 27, 2008

After almost losing a leg for America, Benedict Arnold expected more.

Admired by revolutionary leaders, twice wounded in courageous fighting, Arnold could easily have seen his accomplishments chiseled onto every Revolutionary War memorial in the country. Instead, his name is a historical sneer.

Before he soured on the revolutionary cause, Benedict Arnold was a celebrated hero.
Before he soured on the revolutionary cause, Benedict Arnold was a celebrated hero.
(Brown University Library/Bridgeman Art Library)

His unforgivable act of treason has often been attributed to a flawed character, but the real story is sadder and more complex. After so many sacrifices, he became disillusioned with the war's progress. Perhaps even more important, he grew deeply mistrustful of the cause's civilian leaders and, ultimately, Arnold himself felt betrayed. "This was a man who began in 1775 as the most ardent of patriots," says James Kirby Martin, a history professor at the University of Houston, "but he grew to feel that turning back to England would be the best course for the country."

Arnold was the second of six children born to a close-knit and prosperous family in Norwich, Conn., in 1741. His mother sought solace in religion and his father in alcohol after three of Arnold's siblings died of diphtheria. Expecting to attend Yale, the 14-year-old was instead apprenticed to an apothecary in New Haven. When his mother died and his father turned into the town drunk, Arnold had an early taste of the disgrace that would color the rest of his life.

Ambition and business acumen propelled Arnold from merchandising to international trade. He had made enough money by 22 to buy back the family homestead sold to pay his father's debts. He resold it at enough of a profit to buy a fleet of ships. In 1767, he married the daughter of a prominent Freemason.

But soon squeezed by oppressive British taxes and policies, which imperiled his livelihood, the short and intense patriot devoted himself to resisting British tyranny by joining and then leading the local chapter of the Sons of Liberty.

Hannibal. Untrained and poorly equipped troops frustrated Arnold, so he used his own money and time to train patriot forces. In May 1775, he helped launch an attack on the small British fort of Ticonderoga. A bloodless victory whetted his appetite for military maneuvering and led to Washington appointing him commander of 1,100 men for a campaign against Quebec. Three hundred fifty miles the troops trudged through rain, snow, and ice, reduced to eating candles, dogs, and shoe leather. The Americans' march through the Maine wilderness earned Arnold the undying respect of his men and the nickname "America's Hannibal." During Arnold's recovery from a musket ball to the leg, Thomas Jefferson praised him before the Continental Congress.

Yet Arnold never truly felt his nation's grati-tude. Petty jealousies kept his name off lists of promotions. Inferior military officers generated rumors that pockmarked his reputation. "Virtue is a key concept in the Revolution," says Martin, author of Benedict Arnold, Revolutionary Hero: An American Warrior Reconsidered, "and Congress repeatedly insulted Arnold's virtue."

After the triumphant Battle of Saratoga in New York in 1777, his sense of betrayal reached an unbearable pitch, says Dave Palmer, former superintendent of the U.S. Military Acad-emy at West Point and author of George Washington and Benedict Arnold: A Tale of Two Patriots. The courage and stam-ina shown by Arnold and the Americans impressed the French enough to help convince them to join the war and provide critical support to the struggling rebels. But Arnold received a near-fatal shot to the same leg wounded at Quebec and would never walk again without a limp. While Arnold lay immobilized in an Albany hospital, his commander, Major Gen. Horatio Gates, peevishly claimed credit for the British surrender. "Bedridden and helpless, Benedict Arnold gnashed his teeth at the distressing thought of 'Granny Gates' receiving honors won by the blood and grit of better men," writes Palmer.

Reader Comments

American Victory

I thought has been entering my mind alot recentally... would America have won the war if Benedict Arnold hadn't been a patriot?! He wass by far the bravest general that wshington had! He led the force that stopped a British attack from canada that would have have split the 13 colonies in half!!!! Look it up!! He also probably saved the war for America by leading the troops at the Battle of Saratoga!!! ThE americans were being beat, until he he led the charge that brought back the moral of the men and their fighting spirit, he drove the British back, which won the battle for America. which caused the French to join the American cause. (which we all know, w/ out the french AMerica would have lost the war). America might never had become it's own country if it wasn't for Benedict Arnold, "the first hero of the Revolution".

Benedict Arnold

I have paid my respects and visited Beneddict Arnold's final resting place, which is located in the crypt of St Mary's Church Battersea London. Benedict Arnold was a true British hero and I would also point out that his descendants have made substantial and invaluable military contributions to the armed forces of the UK.

Looking for B.A.'s writing

The article references a writing of Arnold's, which he says, "How can Congress allow this army to starve in a land of plenty?"

Does anyone know where this is from? I'd like to use it for my AP History class, but have not been able to locate it thus far. Thanks.

Add your thoughts

Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

advertisement

advertisement

Public Opinion

Can McCain Come Back Against Obama?

Obama has a substantial lead in the polls. Is it too much for McCain to overcome?

A baby kissing an Obama poster for Washington Whispers. Clary Tepper

Send Us Your Campaign Photos

We want to see your personal photos with Barack Obama, John McCain, Joe Biden, and Sarah Palin. Send the best shots of you and the candidates to campaignphotos@usnews.com and we'll post the best on our website over the coming weeks.

Washington Whispers

Washington Whispers

Hiroshima History for Sale

Forget stocks. Historical artifacts are where the big dollars are, and one is going up for sale.

Michael Barone

Michael Barone

Obama May Not Have the Election Locked Up

There are lots of factors that make a Democratic victory uncertain.

Ken Walsh on the Presidency

Ken Walsh (Charlie Archambault for USN&WR)

Having covered the White House for U.S. News full time since 1986, Ken Walsh brings perspective and insight to his magazine column.

advertisement

NEWSLETTER

Sign up today for the latest headlines from U.S. News & World Report delivered to you free.

RSS FEEDS

Personalize your U.S. News with our feeds of blogs and breaking news headlines.

U.S. NEWS MOBILE

U.S. News daily briefings are also available on your mobile device.

WIDGETS

Embed exclusive U.S. News headlines, rankings, columns, and blog postings to your Web site, blog, or social network.

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.