Sunday, November 23, 2008

Eye & Vision

Considering LASIK Surgery? Read This

5 percent of people are dissatisfied, but you can improve the odds of not being among them

Posted April 30, 2008

It's been a little over a year since Joseph Schnell, an elevator construction worker from Philadelphia, had LASIK eye surgery to correct his nearsighted vision. Rather than becoming clearer and sharper, though, Schnell's vision soon was plagued by glare at night, halos, starbursts, and double images. The results, he says, have affected his mood—he became depressed and anxious shortly after the surgery.

Lasik surgery detail.
Video: Vision and Eye Health
Video: Vision and Eye Health

In response to a Food and Drug Administration public forum on LASIK last week, where Schnell and other people shared their experiences with life-altering complications following the procedure, an FDA advisory panel has recommended ways to make warnings of the risks more clear. The panel suggests that photos depicting what people with visual impairment actually see be made available to those considering the surgery, as well as information on conditions such as large pupils and severe nearsightedness, which would disqualify a person from the procedure, and statistics on side effects. The FDA and a number of organizations, including the National Eye Institute and the American Academy of Ophthalmology, have formed a task force to study quality of life post-LASIK and figure out how to minimize problems.

Experts emphasize that serious complication rates are quite rare. Patient satisfaction hovers around 95 percent, according to a worldwide analysis released in March by another task-force member, the American Society of Cataract and Refractive Surgery. Among those remaining, many are simply dissatisfied that LASIK didn't measure up to their expectations—their vision isn't quite 20/20, and they still need reading glasses, for example. According to the FDA, only about 1 percent of patients report worse vision and have permanent side effects like eye pain, dry eye, and poor night vision. (Lots of people experience temporary effects like dry eye, glare, and halos.)

Still, "we want people to understand that not everyone is a candidate for LASIK," says Kerry Solomon, cochair of the task force and a professor of ophthalmology at the Medical University of South Carolina. "The quality-of-life investigation will provide us with additional knowledge on how to select the best candidates."

Meantime, there are steps you can take to minimize the chances of being among the dissatisfied patients.

Pre-Surgery:

  • If you're predisposed to dry-eye syndrome, LASIK can exacerbate the condition, says Marguerite McDonald, a spokesperson for the American Academy of Ophthalmology and a clinical professor of ophthalmology at New York University School of Medicine. Treatment of dry eye is essential before surgery and is usually successful with eyedrops, prescription medication, or tear duct plugs.
  • Any pre-existing conditions like blepharitis (an inflammation of the eyelids), keratoconus (which causes a curvature of the cornea), or severe seasonal allergies can increase the risk of infection and may decrease the success of surgery. Make sure your doctor tests for these and treats them effectively before going ahead with the surgery.
  • Contact lenses can distort the shape of the cornea, according to McDonald, making it harder for surgeons to take accurate measures of the eye's refractive power. The FDA recommends patients who wear soft contact lenses switch to glasses full time two weeks before the first preop evaluation. That would be three weeks for toric soft lenses for astigmatism and four weeks for hard lenses.

Post-Surgery:

  • Accidentally bumping or rubbing your eyes, even while asleep, can disturb the thin flap of cornea the doctor cuts in order to reshape the cornea beneath. If a flap has wrinkles, the patient may be more susceptible to visual impairment and will likely require corrective surgery, which is typically included in the cost of the original procedure.
  • Halos, ghosting images, nighttime glare, and starbursts can interfere with vision after LASIK and may be caused by naturally larger pupils or under- or over-treatment with the laser. For the vast majority of patients, these side effects improve after a few months. If they remain, however, consult a doctor who may suggest eyedrops or retreatment.

Reader Comments

Permanent adverse effects of EVERY LASIK

What is most important for us all to consider now is the growing body of evidence accumulating in peer-reviewed Ophthalmology journals that indicate that LASIK is a harmful procedure.

Despite claims made by surgeons and the industry about ‘patient satisfaction’, today’s happy 20/20 LASIK patients are often today’s dangerous drivers on our highways at night due to LASIK-induced loss of contrast sensitivity, and may ultimately experience debilitating late-onset complications of LASIK.

Patients who report that they are currently happy with the LASIK procedure likely have no idea of the nature and extent of damage they incurred during the LASIK procedure and the consequences of this damage for their future ocular health and vision. I believe that no patient would want this surgery if they fully understood its consequences.

Here is a short list of permanent adverse effects of LASIK eye surgery:

1. The flap never heals – it just seals a bit around the edges like a Tupperware lid, leaving patients who have had LASIK susceptible to traumatic flap injury for life.

2. LASIK separates the stronger anterior cornea, leaving only the weaker posterior cornea to support the intraocular pressure of the eye. This can lead to corneal ectasia and corneal failure months or years after surgery.

3. LASIK causes permanent pathological changes in all corneas. According to an Emory University study that examined post-mortem LASIK corneas, “A spectrum of abnormal histopathologic and ultrastructural findings was present in all corneas.” Some examples of these findings include deranged and disorded collagen fibers, granules under the flap, and epithelial ingrowth under the flap.

4. There is no evidence that corneal nerves ever fully regenerate to their normal patterns and density after LASIK.

5. LASIK complicates future cataract surgery.

6. LASIK invalidates intraocular pressure measurement, which is critical in the diagnosis of glaucoma.

7. Perhaps gravest of all, Mayo clinic researchers recently found that all patients undergoing laser corneal refractive surgeries lose keratocyte (or corneal stromal cell) density at higher rates even years after surgery. Apparently, excimer laser ablation of corneal stroma results in progressive cell loss in the cornea.

In the peer discussion following this study, LASIK surgeon Dr. Roger F. Steinert commented, and I quote him:

“One can speculate that this loss might lead to corneal ectasia.”

Clearly, patient satisfaction surveys are no substitute for objective quantitative testing, particularly when the technology for performing objective tests is widely available.

I ask that the FDA abandon the proposed quality of life study in favor of a study which objectively and quantitatively measures aspects of post-LASIK dry eye disease and post-LASIK visual quality. Withdrawal of FDA approval for the LASIK procedure should be immediate.

The odds of side effects

After reading the artical in US News,I would like to know what the numbers are of the persons who have had successful lasik eye surgery in comparison to the persons having side effects.As we all know with medical practices as well as perscription medications they are not all ment for everyone because of specific side effects.

sqJHYAcTxUCCSYy

g3498K htdioghrdeioh uerhuy h3oh iohgdfiogho isdfhio sdjhdf

Add your thoughts

Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

advertisement

advertisement

advertisement

Featured Video

Healthination video

Smoking Cessation

Smoking causes damage in more than just the lungs. Find out the many ways to quit smoking.

Bladder Control Problems

Bladder control problems are very common in both men and women.

Breast Self-Exam

Step-by-step instruction on how to perform a breast self-exam.

Arthritis: Pain in Your Joints

What you can do right now to ease the pain of arthritis.

Healthination Video

Adult ADHD: Signs & Symptoms

Learn how adults are diagnosed and about the various treatment methods.

Healthi Nation Video

Birth Control Methods

Learn about condoms, diaphragms, and other barrier methods of birth control.

advertisement

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.
Make USNews.com your home page.